NYC Denies Another 9/11 Toxin Data Request, Prompting Lawsuit

Advocates say city officials are playing 'three-card monte' with critical public health records.

Mar. 30, 2026 at 3:28pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A photorealistic painting of a firefighter's helmet sitting alone on a desk, the warm light and deep shadows creating a somber, reflective mood.The city's refusal to release critical data on the 9/11 toxins continues to cast a long shadow over the lives of survivors and first responders.NYC Today

New York City has denied another request for data about the toxins that were present at Ground Zero after 9/11, despite the recent discovery of 68 boxes worth of relevant information. Advocates for 9/11 survivors are now suing the city, accusing officials of repeatedly refusing to release the records and 'playing hide and seek with people's lives'.

Why it matters

The toxins released during the 9/11 attacks have had long-lasting health impacts on first responders and survivors, many of whom have developed serious illnesses. Access to comprehensive data on these toxins is critical for understanding the scope of the public health crisis and providing appropriate care and support.

The details

The city has claimed it could not find any records related to the 9/11 toxins, even though 68 boxes of such information were discovered just four months ago. Advocates have filed a new lawsuit seeking a court order to force the city to produce the records, after a previous lawsuit led to the uncovering of the 68-box trove.

  • The city denied the latest request for 9/11 toxin data in March 2026.
  • 68 boxes of relevant information were discovered just four months prior to the latest denial.

The players

New York City

The municipal government that has repeatedly denied requests for data on the toxins present at Ground Zero after the 9/11 attacks.

Andrew Carboy

An attorney representing advocates for 9/11 survivors, who has filed a new lawsuit against the city for its refusal to release the records.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“With its ever-changing replies, the city plays three-card monte with Sept. 11 records.”

— Andrew Carboy, Attorney

What’s next

The new lawsuit filed by the advocates will seek a court order to compel the city to release the 68 boxes of 9/11 toxin data that were recently discovered.

The takeaway

This case highlights the ongoing struggle to access critical public health information related to the 9/11 attacks, despite the city's claims that such data does not exist. Transparency and accountability around the long-term impacts of the 9/11 toxins remain elusive, to the detriment of affected survivors and first responders.