Mayor's 'Empty Rikers' Plan Risks Spiking Crime Rates

Correction Commissioner says new jails won't be ready until 2029, but mayor wants to release more detainees now.

Mar. 30, 2026 at 1:04pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An extreme close-up of a pair of handcuffs against a stark black background, creating a gritty, investigative aesthetic that conceptually represents the high-stakes debate over criminal justice reform and public safety.As tensions over criminal justice reform escalate, a push to rapidly empty Rikers Island raises fears of another spike in violent crime.NYC Today

Mayor Zohran Mamdani's push to significantly reduce the Rikers Island jail population is being criticized as a repeat of policies that led to a spike in violent crime in recent years. Most Rikers detainees face serious felony charges, and the city's own Correction Commissioner says new borough-based jails won't be ready until 2029, raising concerns that releasing detainees prematurely could endanger public safety.

Why it matters

The mayor's plan to shrink the Rikers population in order to make the 'replace Rikers' plan more feasible is seen as reckless, as the majority of detainees face serious felony charges and their release could lead to another surge in violent crime like what occurred when similar policies were implemented in 2019-2020.

The details

As veteran prosecutor Jim Quinn notes, 95% of those currently jailed at Rikers are awaiting trial on felony charges, mostly for murder or other violent offenses. The no-bail law also doesn't allow the jailing of those facing 'non-violent' charges like car theft or burglary, except in certain aggravating circumstances. Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards has stated that the first new borough-based jail facility is not expected to be completed until 2029, raising concerns that releasing detainees now could have disastrous consequences.

  • In 2019-2020, state 'reforms' led to the premature release of 2,000 Rikers detainees, followed by Mayor de Blasio releasing another 2,000 in the name of reducing COVID spread.
  • This resulted in a violent crime spike in 2020-2021 that the city is still working to reverse.

The players

Zohran Mamdani

The mayor of New York City who is pushing to significantly reduce the Rikers Island jail population.

Stanley Richards

The Correction Commissioner of New York City who has stated that the first new borough-based jail facility is not expected to be completed until 2029.

Jim Quinn

A veteran prosecutor in Queens who notes that 95% of those currently jailed at Rikers are awaiting trial on felony charges, mostly for murder or other violent offenses.

Bill de Blasio

The former mayor of New York City who released 2,000 Rikers detainees in 2020 in the name of reducing COVID spread, leading to a spike in violent crime.

Laura Swain

The federal judge who is supposed to enforce the decrees 'mandating' improvement at Rikers, but has given a 'remediation manager' up to seven years to get it done.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“The first borough-based jail facility is not expected to reach substantial completion until 2029.”

— Stanley Richards, Correction Commissioner

“95% of those now jailed at Rikers awaiting trial face felony charges, mostly for murder or another violent offense.”

— Jim Quinn, Veteran Queens Prosecutor

What’s next

The judge overseeing the federal consent decree at Rikers will decide whether to grant the 'remediation manager' up to seven years to bring the jail into compliance.

The takeaway

This case highlights the risks of prematurely releasing serious offenders from Rikers, as past attempts to reduce the jail population have led to dangerous spikes in violent crime that the city is still struggling to reverse. Improving conditions at Rikers should be the priority, not emptying the jail before adequate replacement facilities are ready.