Batavia Burger Joint Nominated for Best in New York

The Tiny Piney's signature double smash bacon cheeseburger is one of 40 finalists in the New York Beef Council's annual competition.

Mar. 24, 2026 at 7:03am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Beef Council of New York State has announced its Top 40 nominations for the "Best Burger In New York," and a burger from The Tiny Piney in Batavia, New York is in the running. The Tiny Piney is known for its burgers and volleyball, with its signature item being a double smash bacon cheeseburger. Voting for the "Best Burger in New York" title is open until April 10, 2026.

Why it matters

The Tiny Piney's nomination highlights the growing reputation of Western New York's burger scene, which has produced several standout options in recent years. A win for The Tiny Piney would bring regional pride and recognition to Batavia and the surrounding area.

The details

The Beef Council's annual "Best Burger In New York" competition features 40 nominated burgers from across the state. The Tiny Piney's double smash bacon cheeseburger is the lone Western New York representative in the running. Customers can vote for their favorite burger on the Beef Council's website until the April 10th deadline.

  • Voting for the "Best Burger in New York" competition is open until April 10, 2026.

The players

The Tiny Piney

A burger and volleyball spot located on East Main Street in Batavia, New York, known for its signature double smash bacon cheeseburger.

Beef Council of New York State

The organization that runs the annual "Best Burger In New York" competition to crown the state's top burger.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Voting for the "Best Burger in New York" competition will close on April 10, 2026. The winner will be announced shortly after.

The takeaway

The Tiny Piney's nomination in the Beef Council's "Best Burger In New York" competition showcases the growing culinary reputation of Western New York's burger scene. A win for the Batavia establishment would bring well-deserved regional recognition and pride.