Democrats Weigh Ousting Schumer as Senate Minority Leader

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Frustration with Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer is intensifying among some Democrats, with conversations quietly underway about whether he should step aside after the midterm elections, according to a Wall Street Journal report. Some lawmakers, including Sen. Chris Murphy, have been conducting informal vote counts to gauge support for removing Schumer from his leadership post, though Murphy later said he does not recall referencing any specific tally. Senators like Elizabeth Warren and Tina Smith have grown dissatisfied with Schumer's negotiating style and candidate strategy, and some progressive lawmakers have even discussed countering Schumer-backed candidates in key races.

Why it matters

Schumer's leadership has come under scrutiny as some Democrats view him as an obstacle to change, slowing the party's drive to stand up to President Trump and thwarting a new generation of leadership from rising. The potential ouster of the long-serving Senate Minority Leader could have significant implications for the Democratic Party's strategy and direction heading into the crucial midterm elections.

The details

Sen. Chris Murphy (D-CT) told progressive activists during a February dinner that lawmakers had been conducting informal vote counts to gauge whether enough support existed to remove the New York Democrat from his leadership post. Murphy later said he does not recall referencing any specific tally, but the disclosure revealed that frustration inside the Senate had reached a high enough level that some Democrats were actively contemplating how to oust Schumer. A group of senators, including Elizabeth Warren and Tina Smith, have grown dissatisfied with Schumer's negotiating style and his approach to candidate strategy ahead of November's elections. Some progressive lawmakers, dubbed the 'Fight Club,' have even discussed countering Schumer-backed candidates in key races.

• In February 2026, Sen. Chris Murphy disclosed that lawmakers had been conducting informal vote counts to gauge support for removing Schumer as Senate Minority Leader.
• The Wall Street Journal report was published on March 21, 2026.

What they’re saying

What’s next

The Wall Street Journal report indicates that some Democrats are quietly considering potential replacements for Schumer as Senate Minority Leader, with names like Chris Van Hollen, Catherine Cortez Masto, and Brian Schatz circulating as possible successors. However, the timeline for any potential leadership change remains unclear.