NYC Mayor Hosts Iftar Dinner at City Hall, Sparking Controversy

Critics claim the event is a symbolic message of Islam's 'conquest' of the city

Mar. 12, 2026 at 11:19pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani hosted an Iftar dinner at City Hall, where staff and guests were seen sitting on the floor with American and NYC flags displayed behind them. The event has sparked controversy, with critics claiming it is a symbolic message that Islam has 'conquered' the city less than 25 years after the 9/11 attacks. One guest was seen flashing what appears to be an ISIS hand signal, further fueling concerns about the mayor's ties to Islamist factions.

Why it matters

The Iftar event at City Hall is seen by some as a troubling sign of the growing influence of Islam in New York City politics and a potential threat to the city's traditional American and secular values. The controversy highlights ongoing tensions between the city's Muslim community and those who fear the religion is gaining too much power and influence.

The details

Mayor Mamdani hosted the Iftar dinner at City Hall, where staff and invited guests were photographed sitting on the floor with American and NYC flags displayed behind them. One guest was seen flashing what appears to be an ISIS hand signal. The event follows Mamdani's previous hosting of an Iftar dinner at Gracie Mansion, which occurred shortly after two ISIS followers attempted to bomb an anti-Islam protest outside the residence.

  • The Iftar dinner at City Hall took place on March 12, 2026.
  • The previous Iftar dinner at Gracie Mansion occurred during Ramadan earlier in 2026.

The players

Zohran Mamdani

The current mayor of New York City, who has been accused of promoting Islamist influences in the city's government.

Mahmoud Khalil

An antisemitic individual who was hosted by Mamdani for an Iftar dinner at Gracie Mansion.

Brigitte Gabriel

An anti-Islamic activist born in Lebanon who criticized the symbolism of the Iftar event at City Hall.

Rep. Brandon Gill

A Republican Texas congressman who criticized the Iftar event as an attempt by Islam to 'conquer the West.'

Laura Loomer

A conservative anti-Islam activist who commented on the guest at the Gracie Mansion Iftar dinner flashing what appeared to be an ISIS hand signal.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“People need to understand the symbolism of this. Islam is all about symbolism and projecting their dominance. New York City has been conquered and Mamdani is proclaiming it to the Islamic world.”

— Brigitte Gabriel, Anti-Islamic activist

“They don't want to 'keep religion out of politics,' they want Islam to conquer the west.”

— Rep. Brandon Gill, Republican Texas congressman

“Mamdani for ISIS? A Muslim who was invited to the NYC Mayoral Residence by @ZohranKMamdani for a Ramadan iftar yesterday flashed the ISIS one finger salute inside Gracie Mansion. This comes after 2 ISIS terrorists threw a bomb at Amercians in NYC this weekend.”

— Laura Loomer, Conservative anti-Islam activist

What’s next

The controversy over the Iftar event at City Hall is likely to continue, with calls for Mayor Mamdani to address concerns about his ties to Islamist factions and the symbolism of the event. The mayor's response to criticism will be closely watched.

The takeaway

The Iftar dinner at New York City Hall has become a flashpoint in the ongoing debate over the role of Islam in American politics and society. The event's critics see it as a troubling sign of the growing influence of Islamist ideology in the city, while the mayor and his supporters argue it is simply an inclusive celebration of the city's diversity. The controversy highlights the deep divisions and mistrust that exist around these issues.