Feds Won't Fight Dismissal of Death Penalty Charges Against Mangione

Prosecutors will not appeal judge's order to drop two capital counts against accused healthcare CEO killer

Published on Feb. 28, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Federal prosecutors have announced they will not challenge a judge's order dismissing the two death penalty-eligible counts previously filed against accused healthcare CEO assassin Luigi Mangione. The case against Mangione, who faces separate state murder charges, is now proceeding toward a federal trial later this year.

Why it matters

This decision by federal prosecutors removes the possibility of Mangione facing the death penalty in the federal case, which has been a source of tension with state prosecutors who want to try him first on the state murder charges. The timing of the two trials has been a point of contention between the courts.

The details

Mangione, 27, is accused of gunning down UnitedHealthcare executive Brian Thompson in late 2024. The federal case was scheduled to begin jury selection in September, with trial starting in October, while the state case was initially set to start in June but may now be pushed back to September to align with the federal timeline. The federal judge overseeing the case said she would not coordinate the timeline with state prosecutors unless they reached out to her directly, leading the state judge to suggest the federal government had 'reneged' on an agreement to let the state case go first.

  • The federal case is scheduled to begin jury selection in September 2026, with trial starting in October.
  • The state case was initially set to start on June 8, 2026 but may now be pushed back to September 8, 2026 to align with the federal timeline.

The players

Luigi Mangione

A 27-year-old man accused of killing UnitedHealthcare executive Brian Thompson in late 2024. He faces both federal and state murder charges.

Margaret Garnett

The U.S. District Judge overseeing the federal case against Mangione.

Gregory Carro

The Acting Manhattan Supreme Court Justice overseeing the state case against Mangione.

Brian Thompson

The UnitedHealthcare executive who was allegedly killed by Mangione in late 2024.

Harvey Weinstein

The disgraced Hollywood producer who has hired three attorneys from the firm defending Mangione to represent him at his third New York rape trial.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It appears that the federal government has reneged on their agreement to allow the state to do most of the work on this case.”

— Gregory Carro, Acting Manhattan Supreme Court Justice (amny.com)

What’s next

The federal case against Mangione is scheduled to begin jury selection in September 2026, with trial starting in October. The state case may be pushed back to September 8, 2026 to align with the federal timeline.

The takeaway

The decision by federal prosecutors to not challenge the dismissal of the death penalty-eligible charges against Mangione removes the possibility of him facing capital punishment in the federal case, but the timing of the two trials remains a point of contention between the state and federal courts.