Crumbl Cookie Flavors Ranked: The Best and Worst

From the worst to the absolute best, a brutally honest guide to Crumbl's cookie lineup.

Published on Feb. 21, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

In a detailed review, the author ranks 15 different Crumbl cookie flavors - 5 bad, 5 good, and 5 exceptional. The review covers a range of unique and classic flavors, from the Everything Bagel and Bubblegum cookies to standouts like the Dubai Chocolate Brownie and Strawberry Heart Cake.

Why it matters

Crumbl Cookies has rapidly grown into a national phenomenon, with customers eagerly awaiting the weekly rotation of new and creative flavors. This in-depth ranking provides valuable insight for Crumbl fans on which flavors are worth trying and which ones to potentially skip.

The details

The author sampled a wide variety of Crumbl cookie flavors and shares their honest, no-holds-barred opinions. The worst-ranked cookies include the Everything Bagel, PB&J, Bubblegum, Wildberry Sugar, and Orange Creamsicle, which the author found to be disappointing or not living up to their concepts. On the positive side, the author highlights the M&M's Candies, Martha Stewart Coconut Layer Cake, Sundae Brownie, Carrot Cake, and Pink Velvet Cake as standout good flavors. The top 5 cookies are crowned as the Dubai Chocolate Brownie, Dubai Chocolate Strawberry Brownie, Strawberry Heart Cake, Pumpkin Square Cake, and Martha Stewart NY Strawberry Cheesecake, which the author deems to be "to-die-for" creations.

  • The article was published on February 21, 2026.

The players

Swan Dawg88

The author of the article, who has tried nearly all of Crumbl's cookie flavors and provides a brutally honest ranking of the best and worst.

Amaury Guichon

A renowned pastry chef, mentioned in the context of the author's disappointment with the Everything Bagel cookie not living up to the quality of Guichon's chocolate creations.

Martha Stewart

The famous lifestyle icon, whose Coconut Layer Cake and New York Strawberry Cheesecake cookies are highlighted as standout flavors.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It's about the size of a bagel. It looks just like an everything bagel. One would hope to bite into one of Amaury Guichon's chocolate creations, but instead... SMH. Just be grateful you weren't one of the ones to put this on your tongue.”

— Swan Dawg88, Author (buzzfeed.com)

“Coconut isn't for everyone, but if it's for you, then you'll understand this choice. Martha Stewart knows why she's famous, and after the first bite, you'll know too.”

— Swan Dawg88, Author (buzzfeed.com)

“The pink velvet melts in your mouth, leaving you seeking more. There should be a warning attached to this cake. Warning: You will want many, many, many, many, and many more!”

— Swan Dawg88, Author (buzzfeed.com)

What’s next

Crumbl Cookies frequently rotates new and seasonal flavors, so fans will want to keep an eye out for the next batch of unique cookie creations.

The takeaway

This in-depth review provides valuable insights for Crumbl Cookies fans, helping them navigate the ever-changing lineup of flavors and identify the must-try standouts as well as the ones that may be worth skipping.