High-Achieving Employee Stops Overachieving After Punishment

Employee decides to only meet minimum requirements after boss reprimands him for falling one case short on a sick day

Published on Feb. 20, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A high-achieving employee at a company that handles complaints regularly exceeded his daily quota of 40 cases, often handling 50-55 cases per day. However, after he fell one case short on a sick day, his boss punished him by making him attend a 3-day HR workshop on meeting requirements. Outraged, the employee decided he would only do the minimum 40 cases per day going forward, much to the frustration of his manager.

Why it matters

This story highlights the potential pitfalls of strict quotas and punitive measures against high-performing employees, which can backfire and lead to decreased productivity. It also raises questions about the effectiveness of HR workshops and whether they are the best way to address performance issues.

The details

The employee regularly exceeded his daily quota of 40 cases, handling 50-55 cases per day for the past two years. However, on one sick day, he only handled 39 cases due to bad luck with more time-consuming cases. His boss then required him to attend a 3-day HR workshop on how to meet the 40-case requirement, even though the employee's weekly, monthly, and yearly numbers were well above the target. Angered by this, the employee decided to only do the minimum 40 cases per day going forward, much to the frustration of his manager.

  • The employee regularly exceeded his daily quota for the past two years.
  • On a recent sick day, the employee only handled 39 cases.
  • The next Monday, the employee had an 'emergency 1-on-1' with his manager and was required to attend a 3-day HR workshop.

The players

The Employee

A high-achieving employee who regularly exceeded his daily quota of 40 cases, often handling 50-55 cases per day for the past two years.

The Manager

The employee's manager who required him to attend a 3-day HR workshop after he fell one case short on a sick day, despite the employee's consistently high performance.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Basically it was a workshop for underperformers who had 20-30 out of 40 cases daily.”

— The Employee (twistedsifter.com)

“I will 'reach the 40' and that's it.”

— The Employee (twistedsifter.com)

What’s next

The employee plans to continue only doing the minimum 40 cases per day, despite his manager's frustration, in order to protest the unfair treatment.

The takeaway

This story highlights the potential risks of strict quotas and punitive measures against high-performing employees, which can backfire and lead to decreased productivity. It also raises questions about the effectiveness of HR workshops and whether they are the best way to address performance issues.