We Tried 5 Celebrity Salad Recipes and Found a New Potluck Favorite

Allrecipes' Nicole McLaughlin tested and ranked salads from Bethenny Frankel, Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Aniston, Matthew McConaughey, and Guy Fieri.

Published on Feb. 18, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Allrecipes' own Nicole McLaughlin tried and rated five salad recipes hailing from some of our favorite celebrities to find the best. From Matthew McConaughey's internet-famous tuna salad to Jen Aniston's protein-packed "Friendship Salad," McLaughlin put the recipes to the test and shared her honest reviews.

Why it matters

Celebrities' culinary preferences have long fascinated the public, and their shared recipes offer a glimpse into their personal lives and tastes. This taste test provides insight into which celebrity salads are worth trying, especially for potluck gatherings.

The details

McLaughlin tested five celebrity salad recipes, including Bethenny Frankel's chicken salad, Cameron Diaz's crunchy corn salad, Jennifer Aniston's "Friendship Salad," Matthew McConaughey's tuna salad, and Guy Fieri's mac salad. She rated each recipe on a 10-point scale, with Fieri's mac salad earning the top score of 9.1 for its bold flavors and lack of sweetness.

  • The recipes were tested and rated in February 2026.

The players

Nicole McLaughlin

A food content producer at Allrecipes who tested and reviewed the celebrity salad recipes.

Bethenny Frankel

A former "Real Housewives of New York" star, entrepreneur, and TikTok personality who shared her chicken salad recipe.

Cameron Diaz

An actress who shared a recipe for a crunchy corn salad.

Jennifer Aniston

An actress known for her "Friendship Salad" that she reportedly ate daily on the set of "Friends."

Matthew McConaughey

An actor who shared his unconventional tuna salad recipe.

Guy Fieri

A celebrity chef known for his show "Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives" who shared a recipe for mac salad.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“A purist's chicken salad”

— Nicole McLaughlin, Food content producer (Allrecipes)

“Really not fancy or pretentious. It's like an everyday people's salad”

— Nicole McLaughlin, Food content producer (Allrecipes)

“The perfect snack to keep on hand”

— Nicole McLaughlin, Food content producer (Allrecipes)

The takeaway

This taste test highlights the wide range of celebrity-approved salad recipes, from classic chicken salad to unconventional tuna salad, that can elevate any potluck or gathering. The winning mac salad from Guy Fieri proves that bold, flavorful salads can be crowd-pleasers.