NYC Mayor Weathers First Major Storm Despite Criticism

Zohran Mamdani avoided a disaster, though political enemies are spoiling to capitalize on operational shortfalls.

Published on Feb. 18, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani faced criticism after a major winter storm resulted in 19 outdoor deaths and 7 indoor deaths. While the city performed over 1,400 shelter placements and 80 involuntary removals, some argue Mamdani lacked managerial experience to handle the crisis effectively. However, experts note the city routinely sees dozens of hypothermia-related fatalities that often go unnoticed due to the strained social safety net.

Why it matters

The storm highlighted ongoing challenges the city faces in supporting vulnerable populations, especially the homeless, during extreme weather events. It also raised questions about Mamdani's leadership and whether his socialist policies and lack of managerial experience hindered the city's emergency response.

The details

During the storm, several people died from exposure, including some with permanent housing. The city performed over 1,400 shelter placements and 80 involuntary removals, but critics argue Mamdani lacked the managerial competence to execute core city services effectively. Mamdani's political opponents have seized on the operational failures to attack his job performance and socialist agenda.

  • The storm occurred in early February 2026.
  • As of February 10, the city had completed 1,400 shelter placements.
  • The city performed more than 80 involuntary removals as of February 10.

The players

Zohran Mamdani

The mayor of New York City, who faced criticism for his handling of the winter storm despite avoiding a larger disaster.

New York Post

A newspaper that published an editorial criticizing Mamdani's managerial competence and execution of core city services.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Though his top goal might be converting New York into a socialist paradise (and slamming Israel), his troops still need to pick up the garbage and clear the snow.”

— New York Post (New York Post)

What’s next

The city is expected to review its emergency response protocols and consider ways to better support vulnerable populations during extreme weather events.

The takeaway

This crisis highlights the ongoing challenges New York City faces in balancing its progressive agenda with the need for effective management of core municipal services, especially during emergencies. It remains to be seen whether Mamdani can learn from this experience and improve the city's ability to protect its most vulnerable residents.