Peanut Butter Sold In New York Recalled Over Blue Plastic

Over 22,000 cases of single-serve peanut butter packs were recalled due to blue plastic contamination.

Published on Feb. 17, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The FDA has confirmed a recall of over 22,000 cases of single-serve peanut butter packs sold across 40 states, including New York. The recall involves products manufactured by Ventura Foods and sold under multiple brands and bulk labels due to the potential presence of blue plastic pieces, which poses a choking and injury risk if consumed.

Why it matters

This recall highlights the importance of food safety and the need for manufacturers to ensure the quality and integrity of their products, especially for widely consumed items like peanut butter. Consumers in New York and across the country will need to check their pantries and be vigilant about any potentially contaminated peanut butter products.

The details

The affected products include single-serve 0.5 oz., 0.75 oz., and 1.12 oz. creamy packs, and 2.12 oz. peanut butter-and-jelly twin packs. Brands involved in the recall include US Foods, Flavor Fresh, Katy's Kitchen (Independent Marketing Alliance), House Recipe (Sysco), Gordon Food Service, and Dyma Brand.

  • The FDA confirmed the recall on February 17, 2026.

The players

Ventura Foods

The manufacturer of the recalled peanut butter products.

FDA

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration that confirmed the recall.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The FDA has classified this as a Class II recall, indicating that consumption "may cause temporary or medically reversible health issues." Consumers in New York and across the affected states should check their pantries and avoid consuming any of the recalled peanut butter products.

The takeaway

This peanut butter recall serves as a reminder for consumers to be vigilant about food safety and to closely inspect product labels, especially for widely consumed items. It also highlights the importance of robust quality control measures by manufacturers to ensure the safety and integrity of their products.