The 9 Greatest Hidden-Gem Horror Masterpieces of the 21st Century, Ranked

From "The Dark and the Wicked" to "Oddity", these underrated horror films deserve more attention.

Published on Feb. 10, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Horror is full of brilliant hidden gems, especially in the 21st century. This article highlights 9 of the greatest underrated and overlooked horror masterpieces from the past two decades, including films like "The Dark and the Wicked", "Tigers Are Not Afraid", "Pulse", "Session 9", "Dog Soldiers", "Strange Darling", "The Ugly Stepsister", "Frailty", and "Oddity". These movies may not have been big hits at first, but have since developed loyal cult followings for their chilling scares, compelling storytelling, and unique approaches to the genre.

Why it matters

Horror fans are always on the lookout for the next great hidden gem, and this list shines a light on some truly exceptional but underappreciated horror films from the 21st century. Many of these movies offer fresh perspectives, innovative approaches, and unforgettable scares that deserve more widespread recognition and appreciation within the genre.

The details

The article covers 9 different horror films from the 21st century that have developed cult followings despite not being major hits upon initial release. It provides a brief synopsis and analysis of what makes each film a hidden gem, highlighting their strengths in areas like creepy atmosphere, shocking twists, compelling characters, and unique blends of horror with other genres like fantasy, crime, and drama. The films span a range of styles and settings, from the supernatural terror of "The Dark and the Wicked" to the dark fairy tale of "The Ugly Stepsister".

  • The article was published on February 10, 2026.
  • It covers horror films from the 21st century, with the most recent title being "Oddity" from 2024.

The players

Daniel Boyer

The author of the article, who has highlighted these 9 hidden-gem horror masterpieces from the 21st century.

Bryan Bertino

The director of the 2020 horror film "The Dark and the Wicked".

Lea Myren

The lead actress in the 2025 horror film "The Ugly Stepsister".

Bill Paxton

The director and actor of the 2001 horror crime thriller "Frailty".

Matthew McConaughey

The Academy Award-winning actor who starred in "Frailty" alongside Bill Paxton.

Damian McCarthy

The director of the 2024 horror film "Oddity".

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Horror is full of those slow successes, the ones that didn't generate much buzz or praise at first, but then slowly garnered a worthy cult following later on.”

— Daniel Boyer, Author (Collider)

The takeaway

This article shines a light on a collection of exceptional but underappreciated horror films from the 21st century, proving that the genre is full of hidden gems waiting to be discovered by adventurous viewers. These movies offer fresh, innovative, and deeply unsettling horror experiences that deserve more widespread recognition and appreciation.