LI 'Puppy-Love Killer' Too Mentally Unfit for Trial, Judge Rules

Austin Lynch, 18, accused of killing ex-girlfriend Emily Finn, ordered held in mental health facility for at least a year

Jan. 30, 2026 at 1:47pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A Long Island judge has ruled that 18-year-old Austin Lynch, accused of killing his ex-girlfriend Emily Finn, is too mentally incapacitated to stand trial at this time. The judge ordered Lynch held in a mental health facility for the next year, where doctors will attempt to restore his competency before deciding if prosecutors can move forward with the case.

Why it matters

Rulings declaring accused killers mentally unfit to stand trial are exceedingly rare in New York, as the bar is set very high. This case highlights the complex legal and mental health issues involved when a young person is accused of a violent crime.

The details

Austin Lynch, 18, was accused of fatally shooting his ex-girlfriend Emily Finn as she was visiting her Long Island home from college on Thanksgiving break. Judge Anthony Senft determined that multiple medical professionals evaluated Lynch and found him too mentally 'incapacitated' to assist in his own defense or understand the charges against him. The judge ordered Lynch held in a secure mental health facility for the next year, after which his mental fitness for trial will be reevaluated.

  • On Thanksgiving break, Emily Finn was visiting her Long Island home when she was killed.
  • On January 30, 2026, the judge ruled that Austin Lynch is too mentally unfit to stand trial for at least a year.

The players

Austin Lynch

An 18-year-old accused of killing his ex-girlfriend Emily Finn in a botched murder-suicide attempt.

Emily Finn

The 18-year-old victim who was killed while visiting her Long Island home from college.

Judge Anthony Senft

The judge who ruled that Austin Lynch is too mentally incapacitated to stand trial for at least a year.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I find that Mr. Lynch is, in fact, incapacitated and could not assist his own attorney in his own defense.”

— Judge Anthony Senft

What’s next

After the year-long stint in a mental health facility, Austin Lynch's mental fitness for trial will be reevaluated by the judge.

The takeaway

This case highlights the high legal bar for declaring an accused killer mentally unfit to stand trial in New York, as well as the complex mental health issues that can arise when a young person is accused of a violent crime.