Two Arrested in Jamestown Shoplifting Incident

Suspects accused of stealing Pepsi and makeup from local business

Published on Feb. 28, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Two people were arrested in Jamestown, New York on February 18, 2026 after police responded to a report of shoplifting at a local business. Officers located the suspects, Michael Pacheco and Amy Robbins, and found Pacheco in possession of the stolen items, which included a 12-pack of Pepsi and an Everyday Essentials makeup set. Both Pacheco and Robbins were charged and transported to the Jamestown City Jail.

Why it matters

Shoplifting is an ongoing issue that impacts local businesses and communities. This incident highlights the importance of vigilant security measures and effective law enforcement response to deter and address such crimes.

The details

According to the Jamestown Police Department, officers from the 2nd Platoon responded to the south side business around 3 p.m. on February 18th after a store employee reported a theft. The employee described the suspect as a white male with a grey beard, blue hoodie and camo pants who had stolen a 12-pack of Pepsi and an Everyday Essentials makeup set before fleeing. Officers located Pacheco, who matched the description, along with Robbins, who was holding the stolen Pepsi. A search of their belongings revealed the stolen makeup set in Pacheco's possession.

  • On February 18, 2026, police responded to the shoplifting report around 3 p.m.

The players

Michael Pacheco

The male suspect who was identified as the shoplifter and found in possession of the stolen items.

Amy Robbins

The female suspect who was with Pacheco and also arrested in connection with the incident.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Pacheco and Robbins were transported to the Jamestown City Jail and held overnight pending arraignment on their respective charges.

The takeaway

This case underscores the ongoing challenge of shoplifting that businesses and communities face, and the importance of effective law enforcement response to address such criminal activity.