Islanders' Matthew Schaefer Shares Name with Local Fans

Two Long Island residents with the same name as the Islanders' rising star defenseman share their experiences.

Apr. 11, 2026 at 4:15pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

An abstract, expressionist painting in vibrant neon colors, with rapid brushstrokes depicting the dynamic movements of a hockey player on the ice, their face and jersey indistinct but the energy and motion of the sport palpable.The shared name between a rising hockey star and local fans creates a unique bond and sense of community around the Islanders' success.Commack Today

The Islanders' 18-year-old first overall draft pick, Matthew Schaefer, has quickly become a fan favorite. But two other Matthew Schaefers from Long Island have found themselves in unique situations due to sharing the same name as the hockey star. The elder Syosset resident had a lighthearted encounter with the player, while the younger Commack resident has had to field jokes from friends. As the Islanders' Schaefer continues to shine, his fellow name-sharers look forward to more memorable interactions.

Why it matters

Having the same name as a rising sports star can lead to both amusing and awkward situations for local residents. This story highlights how a shared name can impact people's everyday lives and social interactions in unexpected ways.

The details

The Islanders' 18-year-old Matthew Schaefer, drafted first overall last year, has become a fan favorite not just for his talent on the ice, but also for his wit and warmth off the ice. A 57-year-old Syosset resident with the same name met the young star at a player meet-and-greet event, and the two shared a funny moment when they realized they shared the same name. Meanwhile, a 22-year-old Matthew Schaefer from Commack has had his friends joke about him being the Islanders' first overall pick, though he has not yet had the chance to meet the hockey star in person. At Islanders games, the number of fans sporting Schaefer jerseys has been a sight to behold for the Commack Schaefer.

  • The Islanders' Matthew Schaefer was drafted first overall in 2025.
  • The Syosset resident met the Islanders' Schaefer at a player meet-and-greet event.
  • The Commack resident attended a recent Islanders game and saw many fans wearing Schaefer jerseys.

The players

Matthew Schaefer

The 18-year-old first overall draft pick of the New York Islanders, who has quickly become a fan favorite for his talent on the ice and his personality off the ice.

Matthew Schaefer

A 57-year-old resident of Syosset, Long Island, who shares the same name as the Islanders' star defenseman.

Matthew Schaefer

A 22-year-old resident of Commack, Long Island, who also shares the same name as the Islanders' star defenseman.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“He seems like a good kid. I wished him well and everything.”

— Matthew Schaefer, Syosset resident

“It was definitely weird, but it was funny.”

— Matthew Schaefer, Commack resident

“Oh, look at all these people repping my jersey!”

— Matthew Schaefer, Commack resident

“They're saying 'Matthew Schaefer' everywhere I go.”

— Matthew Schaefer, Syosset resident

The takeaway

This story highlights the unique experiences that can arise when an ordinary person shares a name with a rising sports star. While it can lead to amusing interactions and a sense of shared identity, it can also result in some awkward or confusing situations. The Schaefers' experiences show how a simple name can have a significant impact on one's daily life.