John Gotti's Grandson Seeks Leniency to Donate Kidney to Mother

Lawyers argue Carmine Agnello, a former reality TV star, has become a model citizen and his incarceration would effectively 'sentence' his mother to death.

Mar. 12, 2026 at 8:41pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Lawyers for Carmine Agnello, the grandson of late Gambino crime boss John Gotti, are seeking leniency in his sentencing for COVID-19 relief fraud, arguing that he has become a model citizen and needs to remain free to donate a kidney to his ailing mother, Victoria Gotti, who is battling end-stage renal disease. Agnello's attorney claims his incarceration would 'effectively sentence' his mother to death, as he is her only compatible donor.

Why it matters

This case highlights the complex personal circumstances that can sometimes arise in criminal sentencing, where factors beyond just the crime itself, such as family medical needs, may be considered. It also touches on the challenges faced by those with famous family legacies, like Agnello, in overcoming public perceptions and establishing their own identities.

The details

Agnello, 39, was convicted of pocketing over $1.1 million in COVID-19 relief loans, much of which he used to fuel a cryptocurrency gambling addiction. However, his lawyer is painting him as a changed man who mentors a fatherless youth in Harlem and is now prepared to donate a kidney to save his mother's life. Victoria Gotti, 63, is battling end-stage renal disease, and Agnello is her only compatible donor. Prosecutors have argued he can still donate from behind bars, but Agnello's lawyer contends that his incarceration would put his mother's life at grave risk.

  • Agnello was convicted of COVID-19 relief fraud in September 2024.
  • Agnello's sentencing hearing is scheduled for this Thursday, March 12, 2026.

The players

Carmine Agnello

The 39-year-old grandson of late Gambino crime boss John Gotti, who was a former reality TV star on 'Growing up Gotti' and is now seeking leniency in his sentencing for COVID-19 relief fraud in order to donate a kidney to his mother.

Victoria Gotti

The 63-year-old mother of Carmine Agnello, who is battling end-stage renal disease and is relying on her son as her only compatible kidney donor.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Carmine entered a world where he was quickly in front of a camera — leading to public fascination, and family legacy that was absolutely unavoidable — and a topic for daily discussion.”

— Dennis A. Clark, Agnello's attorney

“The 'destruction' created by his incarceration would be literal, not figurative.”

— Dennis A. Clark, Agnello's attorney

“He is giving me the GIFT OF LIFE.”

— Victoria Gotti

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Thursday whether to grant Agnello leniency in his sentencing in order to allow him to donate a kidney to his mother.

The takeaway

This case highlights the complex personal circumstances that can arise in criminal sentencing, where factors beyond just the crime itself, such as family medical needs, may be considered by the court. It also underscores the challenges faced by those with famous family legacies in overcoming public perceptions and establishing their own identities.