Rohingya Refugee Death Ruled Homicide: US Border Patrol Under Scrutiny

Shah Alam's death reveals vulnerabilities in how authorities handle detentions and releases of vulnerable individuals

Apr. 11, 2026 at 1:33am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A serene, cinematic painting of a park bench or other political-related object bathed in warm, golden light and deep shadows, conveying a sense of solitude and the weight of a tragic event.The tragic death of a Rohingya refugee in a Tim Hortons parking lot exposes vulnerabilities in how authorities handle detentions and releases of vulnerable individuals.Buffalo Today

The death of 56-year-old Rohingya refugee Nurul Amin Shah Alam, who died after being dropped off by U.S. border agents in a Tim Hortons parking lot, has been ruled a homicide by the Erie County medical examiner's office. The incident has sparked a debate about how authorities treat vulnerable people at the edges of our borders and the need for greater accountability and transparency in the immigration enforcement system.

Why it matters

This case exposes vulnerabilities in how authorities handle detentions and releases of vulnerable individuals, highlighting the need for reforms to ensure humane treatment, timely notification to families, and independent investigations when tragedies occur. It underscores the broader tension between border security and the imperative to treat all people with dignity.

The details

Shah Alam, a 56-year-old Rohingya refugee who was nearly blind and did not speak fluent English, was arrested in February and held for several hours by Border Patrol. He was then dropped off late at night in a Tim Hortons parking lot, with no notification to his family or legal counsel. Five days later, he was found dead miles from the drop-off site. The medical examiner's office determined that his death was caused by complications from a perforated duodenal ulcer, precipitated by hypothermia and dehydration, and labeled the manner of death as homicide.

  • In February, Shah Alam was arrested and held for several hours by Border Patrol.
  • Later that night, Shah Alam was dropped off in a Tim Hortons parking lot with no notification to his family or legal counsel.
  • Five days later, Shah Alam was found dead miles from the drop-off site.

The players

Nurul Amin Shah Alam

A 56-year-old Rohingya refugee who fled genocide and resettled in Buffalo, New York, seeking safety and stability.

U.S. Border Patrol

The federal law enforcement agency responsible for patrolling and securing the United States borders.

Erie County Medical Examiner's Office

The office that conducted the autopsy on Shah Alam and ruled his death a homicide.

New York Attorney General

The state's top law enforcement official who has opened a formal investigation into Shah Alam's death.

Erie County District Attorney's Office

The local prosecutor's office that will review the autopsy and other evidence related to Shah Alam's death.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The Erie County District Attorney's Office says it will review the autopsy and other evidence related to Shah Alam's death. Advocates are calling for reforms to ensure humane treatment, timely notification to families, and accountable handoffs when individuals are transferred between agencies.

The takeaway

The Shah Alam case underscores the need for a serious rethinking of how authorities manage vulnerable detainees and communicate after a crisis. Accountability should be the default, not a hard-won exception, in order to uphold the dignity of every person and maintain public trust in the immigration enforcement system.