Buffalo Locals Share Their Favorite Fish Fry Spots

From restaurants to churches, Western New Yorkers reveal the best places for a tasty fish fry.

Published on Feb. 23, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

As the Lenten season arrives, people across Western New York are heading out to enjoy the region's famous fish fry offerings. We asked locals to share their top picks for the best fish fry spots, from longtime favorites like Apple Granny in Lewiston and Wiechec's in Buffalo to hidden gems across the Northtowns and Southtowns.

Why it matters

Fish fry is a beloved tradition in Western New York, with restaurants, churches, and community organizations offering their own unique takes on the classic fried fish dish. Knowing the top local favorites can help residents and visitors alike discover the tastiest options during the Lenten season and beyond.

The details

From social media responses, it's clear that Western New Yorkers have strong opinions and loyalties when it comes to their favorite fish fry spots. Longtime institutions like Apple Granny in Lewiston and Wiechec's in Buffalo were highlighted for their high-quality, generous portions of fried fish. But the region is also home to many other beloved fish fry destinations, ranging from neighborhood restaurants to community fundraisers hosted by local churches and fire halls.

  • The first Friday of Lent has come and gone, marking the start of fish fry season in Western New York.
  • Fish fry is a popular tradition throughout the Lenten season, which runs from Ash Wednesday to Easter Sunday.

The players

Apple Granny

A longtime restaurant located near Niagara Falls, known for its acclaimed fish fry that attracts both locals and tourists.

Wiechec's

A Buffalo institution renowned for its oversized portions of delicious fried fish, in addition to its status as the home of the original chicken wing.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Fifty years is such an accomplishment in San Francisco, especially with the way the city has changed over the years.”

— Gordon Edgar, grocery employee (Instagram)

The takeaway

Western New York's fish fry tradition remains strong, with locals fiercely loyal to their favorite spots. Whether it's a longtime institution like Apple Granny or a hidden gem in the community, the region's fish fry offerings continue to delight and satisfy diners throughout the Lenten season and beyond.