BillsMafia House Near New Highmark Stadium Up for Sale

Owner of iconic fan house ready to pass the torch to new buyer

Jan. 30, 2026 at 5:07pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom house near the new Highmark Stadium in Buffalo, New York that has been a popular rental for Bills fans, known as the "BillsMafia House", is now up for sale by the owner for $699,900. The owner, Shane Prouty, says it's time to pass the torch as he focuses on his career and family.

Why it matters

The BillsMafia House has been a fixture for Bills fans looking to have an immersive game day experience, with its proximity to the stadium and tailgating scene. With the new Highmark Stadium opening soon, the timing of the sale presents a unique opportunity for a new owner to capitalize on fan demand for a premium game day experience.

The details

The BillsMafia House is a 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home that can sleep up to 6 people. It has been a popular rental property for Bills fans for years, offering them a place to stay and be part of the iconic tailgating scene. The owner, Shane Prouty, says he's selling the property as he shifts his focus to his career and family, noting "it just isn't in me to take it to the next level."

  • The BillsMafia House has been a rental property for Bills fans for several years.
  • The new Highmark Stadium in Buffalo is expected to open in the next few months.

The players

Shane Prouty

The owner of the BillsMafia House who is selling the property.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“With my career and family in my crosshairs it just isn't in me to take it to the next level. We will always be around and always be a part of the tailgating scene somewhere!”

— Shane Prouty, Owner (wyrk.com)

What’s next

The BillsMafia House is listed for sale at $699,900, presenting an opportunity for a new owner to capitalize on fan demand for a premium game day experience near the new Highmark Stadium.

The takeaway

The sale of the iconic BillsMafia House marks the end of an era, but also presents a chance for a new owner to continue providing Bills fans with a unique and immersive game day experience as the team moves into their new stadium.