Epstein's Former Cellmate Claims Government 'Deliberately' Left Them Unprotected

Nicholas Tartaglione alleges authorities placed him with Epstein to ensure both were killed in custody

Published on Feb. 7, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Nicholas Tartaglione, a former police officer who shared a cell with Jeffrey Epstein at the Manhattan Correctional Center, has filed a pardon petition claiming the government intentionally placed him with Epstein and wanted both of them dead. Tartaglione alleges Epstein's prosecutors told him he could walk free if he implicated President Trump in Epstein's crimes, though there is no independent corroboration of this claim. The petition comes amid newly released DOJ files showing unexplained CCTV anomalies from the night before Epstein's death, further fueling questions about the circumstances surrounding the high-profile prisoner's demise.

Why it matters

Tartaglione's claims, if true, would represent a shocking abuse of prosecutorial power and raise serious questions about the government's role in Epstein's death. Even if false, the allegations warrant investigation given the many unanswered questions and inconsistencies surrounding Epstein's suicide. The case highlights ongoing concerns about the treatment of high-profile prisoners and the lack of transparency from authorities.

The details

In his 21-page pardon petition, Tartaglione alleges he was "deliberately placed" in the same cell as Epstein, the world's most high-profile prisoner at the time. Tartaglione, a convicted killer, claims the government "wanted both Epstein and me dead." Twenty-one days before Epstein's death, he was found injured in the cell, but Tartaglione was then removed. On the night before Epstein's body was discovered, FBI agents reviewing CCTV footage observed what they described as "a flash of orange" going up the stairs toward Epstein's cell tier. The DOJ released these files years after Epstein's death, which was ruled a suicide.

  • Twenty-one days before Epstein was found dead, he turned up slumped and semi-conscious with injuries to his neck.
  • On August 9, 2019, at 10:39 PM, FBI agents reviewing CCTV observed "a flash of orange" going up the stairs toward Epstein's cell tier.
  • On August 10, 2019, a corrections officer delivering breakfast found Epstein unresponsive.

The players

Nicholas Tartaglione

A former police officer who shared a cell with Jeffrey Epstein at the Manhattan Correctional Center and has filed a pardon petition alleging the government intentionally placed him with Epstein and wanted both of them dead.

Jeffrey Epstein

The world's most high-profile prisoner at the time, who was found dead in his cell, with his death ruled a suicide by hanging.

Maurene Comey

The lead prosecutor on the Epstein case and the daughter of former FBI Director James Comey.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“It is no coincidence that prior to trial, I was transferred to the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan and deliberately placed in the same cell as Jeffrey Epstein.”

— Nicholas Tartaglione (The Daily Mail)

“Epstein's prosecutors, which were led by none other than my prosecutor, Maurene Comey, told Epstein that if he said President Trump was involved with Epstein's crimes, he would walk free.”

— Nicholas Tartaglione (The Daily Mail)

What’s next

The White House has stated that the submission of Tartaglione's pardon petition "means nothing other than that individual has chosen to submit it," and that the administration is not aware of the letter being referenced. However, the claims in the petition, combined with the newly released DOJ files, warrant further investigation into the circumstances surrounding Epstein's death.

The takeaway

The case surrounding Jeffrey Epstein's death continues to raise troubling questions about the treatment of high-profile prisoners, the potential abuse of prosecutorial power, and the lack of transparency from authorities. The accumulation of unanswered details and unexplained anomalies has eroded public trust and underscores the need for a thorough, independent investigation into what truly happened in that Manhattan jail cell.