Rep. Tonko Calls for Abolishing ICE Amid Concerns Over Shootings, Economic Damage

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Democratic U.S. Congressmember Paul Tonko of New York has called for the end of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), citing recent deadly shootings by agents and damage to the New York economy. Tonko argued that ICE is out of control, is not following its national security mission, and that its enforcement hurts local industries like hospitality, farming, and horse racing.

Why it matters

Tonko's call to abolish ICE reflects growing concerns over the agency's tactics and the impact its enforcement is having on local communities. The debate over the role and future of ICE has become a major political issue, with critics arguing the agency has become overly aggressive and overstepped its bounds.

The details

In a speech at his Albany office, Tonko cited recent incidents such as the teargassing of legal observers, the detaining of children, and the shooting deaths of Alex Pretti and Renee Nicole Good as evidence that ICE is "out of control." He argued the agency is not following its national security mission and is instead targeting migrant workers in industries like hospitality, agriculture, and tourism based on skin color, even if they have no criminal record.

• In 2025, ICE had the deadliest year in decades, with 32 people dying in custody.
• More deaths occurred at ICE facilities in 2026.

What they’re saying