Billy Joel Takes Long Island Home Off the Market

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Billy Joel has taken his 26-acre Long Island estate, named MiddleSea, off the market after failing to find a buyer. Joel originally listed the property for sale in 2023 for just under $50 million while it was undergoing renovations, but got no offers. He then attempted to sell it in three separate pieces last year, listing the 14-acre main house for $29.9 million and two 3-acre buildable lots for $4.95 million each, but still could not find a buyer. The main house was eventually dropped to $25 million, but there were still no takers, so Joel has now removed the entire property from the market, with no word on whether he plans to relist it at a later date.

Why it matters

The inability to sell Joel's Long Island estate highlights the challenges faced by high-end luxury homeowners in the current real estate market, where demand for such properties has softened. It also underscores the musician's attachment to the property, which he has owned since 2002 and has been featured in a HBO documentary about his life.

The details

Joel's Oyster Bay compound, MiddleSea, includes a 20,000-square-foot home with five bedrooms and eight bathrooms, as well as a spa, ballroom, pool, tennis court, bowling alley and more. He originally purchased the 26-acre estate in 2002 for $22.5 million.

• Joel originally listed the property for sale in 2023.
• In 2024, Joel attempted to sell the property in three separate pieces, listing the 14-acre main house for $29.9 million and two 3-acre buildable lots for $4.95 million each.
• The main house was eventually dropped to $25 million in 2025, but still did not find a buyer.