Best Pizza Spots in Atlantic & Cape May Counties, NJ

From classic pies to creative toppings, these are the top pizza destinations in the Jersey Shore region

Published on Mar. 5, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

This article highlights the best pizza places in Atlantic and Cape May counties in New Jersey, as determined by consulting with local foodies, friends, and family members. The list includes both long-standing pizzerias known for their classic, well-done style as well as newer spots that offer creative, high-quality toppings. The article provides details on the unique qualities and history of each featured pizza establishment.

Why it matters

Pizza is a beloved staple food in the Jersey Shore region, and these top-rated pizzerias have built loyal followings by consistently delivering delicious pies made with high-quality ingredients and unique preparation methods. Highlighting the best pizza spots in Atlantic and Cape May counties helps residents and visitors alike discover the top destinations for an authentic Jersey Shore pizza experience.

The details

The article covers several renowned pizza places in the region, including Tony's Baltimore Grill in Atlantic City for its classic, well-done style; Tony Baloney's in Atlantic City for its creative toppings like burrata; The Boiler Room in Cape May for its 800-degree brick-oven pizza; Capri Pizza in Northfield for its high-quality, thin-crust pies; Manco & Manco in Ocean City for its unique sauce-on-top method; and Squares & Fare in Somers Point, which has become a top, in-demand pizza destination. The article also features homemade pizza made by Rob Hurley, who is praised for his exceptional pizza-making skills.

  • The article was published on March 5, 2026.

The players

Tony's Baltimore Grill

A long-standing pizzeria in Atlantic City known for its classic, well-done style and rich history.

Tony Baloney's

An Atlantic City pizzeria known for its creative, high-quality toppings like burrata.

The Boiler Room

A Cape May pizzeria known for its 800-degree brick-oven pizza.

Capri Pizza

A Northfield pizzeria praised for its high-quality, thin-crust pizza and 50-year track record.

Manco & Manco

An Ocean City pizzeria highlighted for its unique sauce-on-top method.

Squares & Fare

A Somers Point pizzeria recognized as a top, in-demand pizza destination.

Rob Hurley

An accomplished home pizza maker praised for his exceptional pizza-making skills.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Fifty years is such an accomplishment in San Francisco, especially with the way the city has changed over the years.”

— Gordon Edgar, grocery employee (Instagram)

The takeaway

The Jersey Shore region is home to a diverse array of exceptional pizzerias, from long-standing classics to innovative newcomers, showcasing the depth and variety of the local pizza scene. These top-rated spots offer residents and visitors alike an authentic taste of the best pizza the area has to offer.