Cape May, Pitman Finalists for USA Today's Best Small-Town Food

Two New Jersey communities make the shortlist for USA Today's annual readers' choice awards.

Published on Mar. 5, 2026

Cape May and Pitman, New Jersey have been named finalists in USA Today's nationwide search for small towns with the best food scenes. The newspaper's expert panel selected 20 contenders for the annual readers' choice awards, evaluating towns with populations of 25,000 or fewer that showcase remarkable culinary talent and exceptional quality.

Why it matters

This recognition highlights the vibrant food cultures in these two New Jersey communities, showcasing their diverse restaurant scenes, artisan bakeries, farmers markets, and other food-focused offerings that have helped put them on the map as dining destinations. It also underscores the growing trend of small towns emerging as culinary hotspots across the country.

The details

According to USA Today, Cape May is described as 'the nation's oldest, and arguably most charming, seaside resort town' with an 'incredible food scene' featuring upscale dining destinations and casual breakfast spots. Pitman is praised for its 'small town charm' and 'surprisingly diverse food scene' ranging from classic diners to contemporary eateries, as well as its bustling downtown area with a variety of global cuisines and food-focused events.

  • Voting is open through March 30, 2026.
  • Winners will be announced on April 8, 2026.

The players

USA Today

A national newspaper and media company that hosts an annual readers' choice awards program recognizing the best small-town food scenes across the United States.

Cape May

A seaside resort town in New Jersey known for its historic charm and diverse culinary offerings.

Pitman

A small town in Gloucester County, New Jersey with a vibrant downtown area and wide range of global cuisine options.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

Readers can vote once per day through March 30, 2026 for their favorite small-town food scenes. The winners will be announced on April 8, 2026.

The takeaway

This recognition of Cape May and Pitman as finalists for USA Today's best small-town food scene underscores the growing culinary appeal of these New Jersey communities, which are leveraging their unique local flavors, diverse dining options, and community-driven food events to attract visitors and showcase their status as emerging gastronomic destinations.