Mays Landing's Iconic Sugar Hill Subs Temporarily Closes Due to Burst Pipes

The legendary sandwich shop will be closed for a few days to address plumbing issues.

Published on Feb. 8, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Sugar Hill Subs, a beloved sandwich shop in Mays Landing, New Jersey, has temporarily closed its doors due to a burst pipe issue. The shop, which has been a local institution since 1982, announced on social media that it will be closed for the next three days to fix the plumbing and give the shop a facelift. Despite the temporary closure, the shop's owner assures customers that they will be back in working order as quickly as possible.

Why it matters

Sugar Hill Subs is a beloved institution in Mays Landing, known for its high-quality, affordable sandwiches that rival even the famous White House Subs in Atlantic City. The temporary closure of this local landmark has caused concern among the community, but the owner's commitment to resolving the issue and reopening quickly should help to alleviate those concerns.

The details

Sugar Hill Subs, located at 5445 Somers Point Road in Mays Landing, announced on Facebook that the shop will be closed for the next three days due to a burst pipe issue. The owner, Gerry Delany, who runs the shop with his wife Denice, said that they were not aware of the harsh winter weather causing the plumbing issue, but that they will be working quickly to fix the problem and give the shop a facelift. Despite the closure, Delany assured customers that they will be back in working order as soon as possible.

  • Sugar Hill Subs announced the temporary closure on February 8, 2026.
  • The shop will be closed for the next 3 days to address the plumbing issue.

The players

Sugar Hill Subs

A legendary sandwich shop in Mays Landing, New Jersey that has been in business since 1982, known for its high-quality, affordable sandwiches that rival even the famous White House Subs in Atlantic City.

Gerry Delany

The owner of Sugar Hill Subs, who runs the shop with his wife Denice.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Hey y'all. So here's the deal. For the next 3 days sugar hill will be under construction due to the pipe burst. We will be fixing the issue and giving the plumbing a face lift”

— Gerry Delany, Owner, Sugar Hill Subs (Facebook)

“As unfortunate as this is, it ensures something like this will hopefully not happen again. It's been awhile since we've had a winter this harsh so this was something we were not aware of and also had no idea would happen.”

— Gerry Delany, Owner, Sugar Hill Subs (Facebook)

What’s next

Sugar Hill Subs plans to reopen as soon as the plumbing issue is resolved, which they expect to be within the next 3 days.

The takeaway

The temporary closure of the iconic Sugar Hill Subs in Mays Landing has caused concern among the local community, but the owner's commitment to quickly resolving the plumbing issue and reopening the shop demonstrates the importance of this beloved institution to the town.