Unique Sneakers Lead to Arrest in Cape May Burglary Case

Suspect's distinctive footwear caught on camera helped crack the investigation.

Mar. 24, 2026 at 8:50am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Cape May police have arrested a 40-year-old Pleasantville man, Vito Anderson, in connection with a burglary at a business on Washington Street earlier this month. Detectives were able to identify Anderson as a suspect after surveillance footage showed him wearing the same unique sneakers, face covering, and gloves during the break-in that he was still in possession of at the time of his arrest. The investigation also linked Anderson to similar burglaries in nearby towns.

Why it matters

This case highlights the importance of forensic evidence, even something as simple as a suspect's clothing and accessories, in solving property crimes. The use of surveillance cameras and the ability to compare evidence across multiple incidents helped police apprehend the alleged perpetrator.

The details

According to the Cape May Police Department, on March 5th a suspect broke into a business on Washington Street. Detectives were able to identify Vito Anderson as the suspect after reviewing surveillance footage that showed him wearing distinctive sneakers, a 'Shystie' face covering, and gloves during the burglary. Police say Anderson was still in possession of the same items when he was arrested, which helped link him to the crime.

  • The burglary occurred on March 5th.
  • Anderson was arrested sometime after the March 5th incident.

The players

Vito Anderson

A 40-year-old man from Pleasantville who has been charged with burglary, theft, and other crimes related to the break-in at a Cape May business.

Dekon Fashaw

The Cape May Police Chief who discussed the details of the investigation and arrest.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“While comparing video surveillance, Anderson was found to use the same clothing to include unique sneakers, a 'Shystie' face covering and gloves to conceal his identity which Anderson was still in possession of at the time of arrest.”

— Dekon Fashaw, Cape May Police Chief

What’s next

The judge will decide on Anderson's bail at a hearing next week.

The takeaway

This case demonstrates how even small details like a suspect's choice of clothing can provide crucial evidence that helps law enforcement solve crimes. The ability to compare surveillance footage across multiple incidents was key in identifying the alleged perpetrator in this burglary investigation.