Couple Charged in Warrington Wegmans Retail Theft

Police say the pair stole over $500 in merchandise, including a $440 bottle of champagne.

Apr. 5, 2026 at 3:52pm

Police in Warrington, Pennsylvania have charged a man and woman in connection with a retail theft incident at a local Wegmans grocery store on December 31. The couple allegedly selected a $440 bottle of Cristal Brut Champagne from a secured area, as well as additional merchandise totaling over $550, before exiting the store without paying.

Why it matters

Retail theft is an ongoing issue for businesses, especially high-end grocery stores like Wegmans that carry expensive specialty items. This incident highlights the need for vigilant loss prevention efforts and potential prosecution of repeat offenders to deter future crimes.

The details

According to police, Warrington officers responded to the Wegmans at 1405 Main Street on January 16 for a report of retail theft. Loss prevention staff reported that a male and female suspect selected the bottle of Cristal Brut Champagne valued at $439.99 from a secured area, as well as additional merchandise, before exiting the store without paying. The total value of the stolen items was $559.43.

  • The incident occurred on December 31.
  • Police were notified and responded on January 16.

The players

Maya Jasmine Alkiyal

A 24-year-old resident of Beverly, New Jersey who has been charged with retail theft and receiving stolen property.

Christopher James Bartorillo

A 25-year-old resident of Clifton Heights who has been charged along with Alkiyal.

Wegmans

A regional supermarket chain known for its high-end offerings and focus on customer experience.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

A criminal complaint has been filed in District Court against both Alkiyal and Bartorillo.

The takeaway

This incident underscores the ongoing challenge retailers face in deterring and prosecuting retail theft, especially for high-value items. It serves as a reminder of the importance of strong loss prevention measures and the potential legal consequences for those who engage in such crimes.