Driver Cleared in 2023 Pedestrian Death Near Portsmouth Park

Yvonne Reed acquitted of reckless manslaughter and negligent homicide charges in fatal crash

Apr. 3, 2026 at 8:24pm

An extreme close-up of a shattered car side mirror lens reflecting the faint outline of a crosswalk, conveying the aftermath of a tragic pedestrian collision through a stark, gritty visual metaphor.The acquittal of the driver in this pedestrian fatality near a popular park has reignited debates over road safety and accountability for fatal crashes.Portsmouth Today

A jury has acquitted Yvonne Reed of reckless manslaughter and negligent homicide charges in the 2023 pedestrian death outside Prescott Park in Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Reed was accused of hitting and killing 53-year-old Robert Mayo with her car in the early morning incident, but was found not guilty after a four-day trial.

Why it matters

The case highlighted ongoing concerns about pedestrian safety and the legal standards for prosecuting drivers involved in fatal crashes, especially in high-traffic areas near public parks and attractions.

The details

According to authorities, the fatal crash occurred on August 1, 2023 before 5 a.m. at the intersection of lower State Street and Marcy Street in Portsmouth. Reed, who was operating a blue Oldsmobile Cutlass Supreme at the time, struck and killed Robert Mayo, a 53-year-old man last known to be living in Hooksett. After the incident, Reed parked the car nearby and reported the crash to police. Both Portsmouth and state police responded to the scene, and the intersection was closed for several hours during the investigation.

  • The fatal crash occurred on August 1, 2023 before 5 a.m.
  • Reed was indicted by a county grand jury in March 2024 on the two charges.

The players

Yvonne Reed

The driver who was accused and acquitted of reckless manslaughter and negligent homicide charges in the 2023 pedestrian death.

Robert Mayo

The 53-year-old pedestrian who was killed in the August 2023 incident near Prescott Park in Portsmouth.

Brett Newkirk

The public defender who represented Yvonne Reed.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“In recognition of the seriousness of the matter and the tragedy of Mr. Mayo's accidental death, I'll reserve my comments for the courtroom.”

— Brett Newkirk, Public Defender

What’s next

The judge will decide on Tuesday whether to allow Yvonne Reed to be released on bail while the case is appealed.

The takeaway

This case highlights the complex legal standards and evidentiary challenges in prosecuting drivers involved in fatal pedestrian crashes, even in high-traffic areas near public spaces. It also raises ongoing questions about improving road safety and protecting vulnerable road users in Portsmouth and similar communities.