Top Chef' Judges Tease Unpredictable Season 23

Longtime judges Tom Colicchio, Kristen Kish and Gail Simmons preview a season with surprising highs and lows

Published on Mar. 9, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The upcoming 23rd season of Top Chef has been surprisingly unpredictable, even for the show's long-time judges. Judges Tom Colicchio, Kristen Kish, and Gail Simmons say the new crop of chefs has delivered standout dishes one challenge and major missteps the next, making the season harder to predict than in recent years. The judges attribute the inconsistency to the dynamics between the contestants and some "real-life stuff" that has happened off-camera.

Why it matters

Top Chef is one of Bravo's longest-running and most popular competition shows, so an unpredictable season could make for especially compelling viewing. The judges' comments suggest the new season will keep audiences on their toes, with no clear frontrunners emerging and the chefs facing unexpected challenges both in and out of the kitchen.

The details

According to the judges, the chefs' performances have been "inconsistent" this season, with the food quality varying dramatically from one challenge to the next. They say the contestants clearly have the talent, but something has been causing them to "fail" at times. Kristen Kish believes the unpredictability will make for "really fun" viewing, while Gail Simmons hints at "drama" and "unforeseen circumstances" happening off-camera that have impacted the competition.

  • Top Chef Season 23 is premiering on Bravo tonight, March 9, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET/PT.

The players

Tom Colicchio

A longtime judge on Top Chef who has been with the show since its debut in 2006.

Kristen Kish

The host of Top Chef since taking over in Season 21, and a former winner of the competition.

Gail Simmons

A judge who has been with Top Chef since the show's debut in 2006 and is also a cookbook author.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We'll do a challenge and all the food is great. Next challenge it's all bad. We haven't seen that in a minute.”

— Tom Colicchio (Parade)

“It is inconsistent, which I think from a viewer perspective is going to be really fun to watch.”

— Kristen Kish, Host, Top Chef (Parade)

“There's been some drama. There's been some unforeseen circumstances, like real-life stuff. And that's made the season really interesting.”

— Gail Simmons, Judge, Top Chef (Parade)

What’s next

Top Chef Season 23 premieres tonight, March 9, 2026 on Bravo at 9 p.m. ET/PT.

The takeaway

This unpredictable season of Top Chef suggests the competition will keep audiences guessing, with no clear frontrunners and the chefs facing unexpected challenges both in and out of the kitchen. The judges' comments hint at a season full of dramatic twists and turns that could make for especially compelling viewing.