Cardinals' Draft-and-Development Process Analyzed

A deep dive into the St. Louis Cardinals' player development system and how it has consistently produced MLB talent.

Apr. 12, 2026 at 3:35pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist-style painting depicting the various elements of player development - scouting, drafting, coaching, and on-field performance - broken down into geometric shapes and planes of color, conveying the complexity and interconnectedness of the process.The Cardinals' player development system has a proven track record of transforming lower-ranked prospects into impactful major leaguers.St. Louis Today

A closer look at the St. Louis Cardinals' draft-and-development process, including an analysis of how the team has been able to consistently turn lower-ranked prospects into productive major league players. The author examines methodologies to better distinguish the impact of the draft versus player development, using prospect ranking data and Zips projections to evaluate organizational trends.

Why it matters

The Cardinals have long been regarded as one of the best player development organizations in baseball, able to extract value from draft picks and international free agents in ways that other teams struggle to match. Understanding the specifics of their approach could provide valuable insights for other teams looking to emulate their success.

The details

The author has been working to refine his analysis methods, focusing on evaluating how players' prospect rankings change from their initial draft/signing grades to their eventual major league production. By looking at organization-wide trends rather than individual cases, the goal is to identify if the Cardinals consistently develop lower-ranked prospects into above-average MLB players at a higher rate than other teams. This involves compiling prospect ranking data going back to 2017 and combining it with Zips 3-year projections to create a more comprehensive view of player development timelines. The author has also calculated an 'Adjusted FV' metric based on projected and actual WAR to compare players on a standardized scale.

  • Spring Training 2026 is underway, providing new data and insights on the Cardinals' player development process.
  • The author has been working on this analysis project over the past winter, compiling data and refining his methodologies.

The players

Shohei Ohtani

A two-way player who has produced at an elite level as both a starting pitcher and hitter, demonstrating the potential for players to excel in multiple facets of the game.

Tarik Skubal

A starting pitcher who has seen a significant jump in his prospect ranking and future projections, potentially indicating strong player development by the Cardinals organization.

Bobby Witt Jr.

A shortstop who was a highly-touted draft pick and has continued to develop into an impact player, providing an example of the Cardinals' ability to maximize the potential of their top prospects.

Garrett Crochet

A relief pitcher who has outperformed his initial prospect ranking, suggesting the Cardinals' player development system may be adept at unlocking the potential of pitchers.

Paul Skenes

A starting pitcher prospect who has shown elite potential, further demonstrating the Cardinals' knack for identifying and developing high-end talent.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The author plans to continue refining his analysis methods, including further data wrangling and incorporating additional prospect ranking and projection data. He is also interested in feedback from readers on his proposed approaches to better distinguish the impact of drafting versus player development.

The takeaway

The Cardinals' consistent ability to develop lower-ranked prospects into productive major leaguers suggests their player development system is a key competitive advantage. Understanding the specifics of their approach could provide valuable insights for other organizations looking to emulate their success.