Kayla Nicole Reflects on Failed Travis Kelce Relationship

The fitness influencer says the breakup could have been a case of 'right person, wrong time'.

Published on Feb. 20, 2026

Kayla Nicole, the ex-girlfriend of NFL star Travis Kelce, has reflected on their failed relationship, suggesting it may have been a case of 'right person, wrong time.' In a TikTok live conversation, Nicole said the breakup, which happened around three years ago after a five-year on-again, off-again romance, could have been due to 'compatibility issues' or simply bad timing. Nicole and Kelce officially split in May 2022, and Kelce has since moved on to a relationship with pop star Taylor Swift.

Why it matters

The breakup between Nicole and Kelce, two high-profile figures in the entertainment and sports worlds, has sparked ongoing speculation and commentary from fans and media. Nicole's candid reflection on the relationship provides insight into the challenges of celebrity dating and the complexities of ending a long-term partnership.

The details

During the TikTok live, Nicole answered questions about her last relationship, which she said was around three years ago. When asked about the breakup with Kelce, she suggested it could have been due to 'compatibility issues' or 'right person, wrong time.' Nicole and Kelce dated for five years, with their relationship being on-again, off-again, before officially calling it quits in May 2022. Since then, Kelce has moved on to a relationship with pop star Taylor Swift, with the two becoming engaged last August.

  • Nicole and Kelce officially broke up in May 2022 after a five-year on-again, off-again relationship.
  • Kelce and Taylor Swift became engaged in August 2025, after two years of dating.

The players

Kayla Nicole

A fitness influencer who previously dated NFL star Travis Kelce.

Travis Kelce

An NFL tight end for the Kansas City Chiefs who previously dated Kayla Nicole and is now engaged to pop star Taylor Swift.

Taylor Swift

A popular American singer-songwriter who is currently engaged to NFL player Travis Kelce.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Who knows? Could be compatibility issues, right person, wrong time.”

— Kayla Nicole, Fitness Influencer (TMZ)

The takeaway

The breakup between Kayla Nicole and Travis Kelce highlights the complexities of high-profile relationships, where factors like compatibility, timing, and public scrutiny can all play a role in the ultimate outcome. Nicole's reflection on the relationship as potentially being the 'right person, wrong time' provides a thoughtful perspective on the challenges of finding lasting love in the public eye.