Murder charges dismissed against five men in 2024 Caruthersville teen's death

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

First-degree murder charges against five Missouri men in connection with the 2024 shooting death of an 18-year-old Caruthersville resident have been dismissed. Second Judicial District Prosecuting Attorney Sonia Hagood announced the decision to file a nolle prosequi, citing ongoing issues with key witnesses in the case.

Why it matters

The dismissal of these charges raises questions about the challenges prosecutors face in securing convictions, particularly when dealing with uncooperative witnesses. It also highlights the complexities of the criminal justice system and the need for thorough investigations and reliable evidence to ensure justice is served.

The details

The five men - Omarion Grant, Jaquavion Edwards, Tyleik Moore, Rodney Jones, and Prince Black - had been charged in the April 2024 shooting death of Kohnali Hunt. During initial trial proceedings in June 2025, several subpoenaed witnesses left the courthouse during jury selection and did not return. A retrial in July resulted in a mistrial when a key witness changed their testimony on the stand, affecting the prosecution's ability to establish identification of the alleged shooters. Prosecutors also cited the inability to secure another material witness currently incarcerated in Missouri.

• The shooting death of Kohnali Hunt occurred in April 2024.
• Initial trial proceedings took place in June 2025.
• A retrial was held in July 2025.

What they’re saying