Homeland Security Chief Noem Faces Bipartisan Criticism Over ICE Turmoil

Noem testifies before Senate Judiciary Committee amid funding impasse and concerns over immigration enforcement operations.

Published on Mar. 4, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem endured sharp questioning from both Democratic and Republican senators during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing focused on recent fatal shootings by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis and broader concerns over the agency's practices and leadership.

Why it matters

The hearing highlighted growing bipartisan scrutiny of the Department of Homeland Security's immigration enforcement tactics and Noem's handling of the agency, as well as a funding impasse that has partially shut down parts of DHS.

The details

Much of the session centered on the January deaths of two Minneapolis residents, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, who were U.S. citizens shot during a large-scale immigration enforcement surge known as Operation Metro Surge. Noem initially labeled Pretti's actions 'the definition of domestic terrorism,' drawing fierce criticism. Senators pressed her to retract the claim, which she declined to do. While most Republicans defended the administration's enforcement push, two GOP senators delivered pointed criticism, with one threatening to stall Senate business unless the department provides answers. The hearing also spotlighted a standoff over DHS funding, with Democrats withholding support for a new appropriations bill unless changes are made to immigration enforcement practices.

  • The hearing took place on Tuesday, March 4, 2026.
  • The fatal shootings in Minneapolis occurred in January 2026.

The players

Kristi Noem

The current Homeland Security Secretary, who endured sharp questioning from senators during the hearing.

Renee Good

A Minneapolis resident who was shot and killed during the federal immigration operation in January 2026.

Alex Pretti

A Minneapolis resident who was shot and killed during the federal immigration operation in January 2026.

Dick Durbin

A Democratic senator who pressed Noem repeatedly to retract her claim that Pretti's actions were 'the definition of domestic terrorism.'

Thom Tillis

A Republican senator who is retiring and who blasted Noem's leadership as a 'disaster,' accusing DHS of prioritizing arrest quotas over accuracy.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“You and your agency rushed to brand these victims as, quote, domestic terrorists.”

— Dick Durbin, Senator

“Quality matters, not quantity.”

— Thom Tillis, Senator

What’s next

Noem is scheduled to testify before the House Judiciary Committee again on Wednesday.

The takeaway

The hearing highlighted the growing bipartisan scrutiny of the Department of Homeland Security's immigration enforcement tactics and Noem's leadership, as well as the political divisions over the administration's mass deportation agenda.