Cailyn Healy Leads Comparion Insurance Agency as Influential Agency Manager

Empowering teams and driving innovation in the insurance industry

Apr. 9, 2026 at 11:23am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A photorealistic studio still-life photograph featuring a stack of insurance policy documents, a pen, and a calculator arranged elegantly on a clean, monochromatic background, symbolizing the strategic leadership and innovation Cailyn Healy brings to the insurance industry.Cailyn Healy's strategic approach and dedication have earned her recognition as a leading innovator in the insurance industry.South Portland Today

Cailyn Healy is a highly accomplished insurance professional with over 15 years of experience in Property & Casualty and Life Insurance. She currently serves as the Agency Manager at Comparion Insurance Agency, where she provides strategic leadership, mentorship, and guidance to a team of licensed agents. Cailyn has focused on driving performance, setting clear goals, and creating tailored business plans to ensure her team's success while supporting organizational growth objectives.

Why it matters

Cailyn's leadership style emphasizes collaboration, continuous improvement, and professional development, creating an environment in which both employees and clients thrive. Her strategic approach and dedication have earned her recognition within the industry, including multiple managerial awards during her tenure at Liberty Mutual.

The details

Cailyn began her career in insurance sales shortly after completing her education, steadily advancing into management roles at Liberty Mutual and Comparion Insurance. She successfully transitioned from sales to full-time recruiting and leadership, finding fulfillment in the tangible impact she has on her community and the professional growth of those she mentors.

  • Cailyn has over 15 years of experience in the insurance industry.
  • She has served as the Agency Manager at Comparion Insurance Agency.

The players

Cailyn Healy

A highly accomplished insurance professional with over 15 years of experience in Property & Casualty and Life Insurance, currently serving as the Agency Manager at Comparion Insurance Agency.

Comparion Insurance Agency

The insurance agency where Cailyn Healy currently serves as the Agency Manager, providing strategic leadership, mentorship, and guidance to a team of licensed agents.

Liberty Mutual

The insurance company where Cailyn Healy previously held management roles before joining Comparion Insurance Agency.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Cailyn attributes her success to a strong work ethic and a supportive network. She emphasizes the importance of building relationships and consistent professional performance, noting that networking remains a critical factor in career advancement.”

— Cailyn Healy, Agency Manager, Comparion Insurance Agency

“Her guidance to young women entering the industry is clear: strive to reach your full potential, work diligently, and support others along the way.”

— Cailyn Healy, Agency Manager, Comparion Insurance Agency

The takeaway

Cailyn Healy's leadership, mentorship, and commitment to community service set a high standard for excellence in the insurance industry, inspiring colleagues, clients, and aspiring professionals to achieve success while making a meaningful impact in their communities.