Eliot Cutler Denies Violating Probation While Jailed

Disgraced former gubernatorial candidate says he can't get court-ordered treatment while in custody

Published on Feb. 25, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Eliot Cutler, a disgraced former Maine gubernatorial candidate, is facing allegations of violating his probation by missing court-ordered treatment for 'problematic sexual behavior.' Cutler denies the allegations, stating he is unable to attend the treatment program because he is currently jailed without bail after being found with pornographic DVDs, which violates his probation conditions.

Why it matters

Cutler's case highlights the challenges of enforcing probation conditions when an individual is incarcerated and unable to comply with court-ordered treatment. It raises questions about how the criminal justice system handles individuals with complex behavioral issues who struggle to meet the terms of their release.

The details

Cutler was arrested earlier this month after Maine State Police found him in possession of pornographic DVDs, which violates the terms of his probation. His probation officer has filed multiple motions to revoke his probation, citing Cutler's alleged failure to comply with treatment requirements. Cutler denies the allegations, stating he is unable to attend the required treatment program because he is currently jailed without bail.

  • Cutler was arrested earlier this month after the incident in South Portland.
  • Cutler was convicted in 2023 for possessing thousands of sexually explicit images of children and sentenced to nine months in jail and six years of probation.
  • Cutler was released from jail two months before his scheduled release date due to 'good behavior.'

The players

Eliot Cutler

A disgraced former Maine gubernatorial candidate who was convicted in 2023 for possessing thousands of sexually explicit images of children and is currently facing allegations of violating his probation.

Sam Payson

Cutler's probation officer, who has filed multiple motions to revoke Cutler's probation.

Robert Granger

The Hancock County District Attorney, who is arguing that Cutler 'created the circumstances that resulted in his inability to attend' his court-ordered treatment.

Walter McKee

Cutler's attorney, who stated that his client is expected to be transferred back to the Hancock County Jail soon.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Mr. Cutler has demonstrated that he has no intent of following his ordered conditions and is simply searching for ways to circumvent them.”

— Sam Payson, Cutler's probation officer (pressherald.com)

“In other words, the State's Motion is premised on the notion that his alleged conduct which prevents attendance at the program was the direct result of his own conscious decisions to not comply with probation and bail.”

— Robert Granger, Hancock County District Attorney (pressherald.com)

What’s next

A judge did not rule on the newest motion to revoke Cutler's bail on Wednesday. Cutler is tentatively scheduled to appear in court again on April 8, but both sides are exploring other dates to ensure all relevant witnesses can be available.

The takeaway

Cutler's case highlights the challenges of enforcing probation conditions when an individual is incarcerated and unable to comply with court-ordered treatment. It raises questions about how the criminal justice system handles individuals with complex behavioral issues who struggle to meet the terms of their release.