Convicted Ocean City Murderer Seeks Sentence Reduction

Benjamin Sifrit, serving 38 years for 2002 killing, petitions under Maryland's Second Look Act

Published on Mar. 6, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Benjamin Sifrit, currently serving a 38-year sentence for the 2002 killing and dismemberment of a Virginia couple in Ocean City, Maryland, has petitioned for a reduced sentence under the state's new Second Look Act. Sifrit was convicted of second-degree murder, first-degree assault and accessory after the fact in the deaths of Martha Gene Crutchley and Joshua Ford. He maintains his innocence regarding the murders, but admits to dismembering and disposing of the bodies. A hearing on Sifrit's petition is set for August 2026.

Why it matters

The case highlights the ongoing debate around sentencing reform and 'second look' laws that allow individuals convicted of crimes as young adults to petition for reduced sentences. Sifrit's petition comes as Maryland's new Second Look Act takes effect, which allows certain offenders to seek sentence reductions after 20 years of incarceration.

The details

In 2002, Benjamin Sifrit and his then-wife Erika were suspects in the killings of Crutchley and Ford, a Virginia couple visiting Ocean City for Memorial Day weekend. The bodies were dismembered and dumped, but later recovered from a Delaware landfill. While Erika was convicted of first and second-degree murder, Benjamin was found not guilty on charges related to Ford's death, but convicted on charges related to Crutchley's death. He was sentenced to a total of 38 years. Now, Sifrit is petitioning for a reduced sentence under Maryland's new Second Look Act, which allows certain offenders convicted as young adults to seek sentence reductions after 20 years.

  • In the summer of 2002, Sifrit was 24 years old when the crimes were committed in Ocean City.
  • Sifrit filed his petition for a reduced sentence in late September 2026.
  • A hearing on Sifrit's petition is set for August 11, 2026.

The players

Benjamin Sifrit

A man currently serving a 38-year sentence for the 2002 killing and dismemberment of a Virginia couple in Ocean City, Maryland. He has petitioned for a reduced sentence under Maryland's new Second Look Act.

Martha Gene Crutchley

One of the victims killed and dismembered by Sifrit and his then-wife Erika in 2002 in Ocean City.

Joshua Ford

The other victim killed and dismembered by Sifrit and his then-wife Erika in 2002 in Ocean City.

Erika Sifrit

Benjamin Sifrit's ex-wife, who was convicted of first-degree murder in Ford's death and second-degree murder in Crutchley's death, and sentenced to life in prison plus 20 years.

Michael W. Farlow

The assistant state's attorney for Worcester County who issued the state's objection to Sifrit's petition for a reduced sentence.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“I was 24 years old in the summer of 2002 when my former wife and I took a week-long vacation to Ocean City, Md. The crimes committed on this trip led to my arrest at a Hooters Restaurant during the burglarizing of the establishment. I was caught in the act and charged with various crimes. I pled guilty and received a three-year sentence.”

— Benjamin Sifrit (Sifrit's petition)

“To be clear, I have always, and still do, maintain my innocence regarding any act of murder.”

— Benjamin Sifrit (Sifrit's petition)

“The State objects to the relief requested with the Defendant's Motion to Reduce Sentence. .... The State respectfully requests that this Honorable Court deny the Defendant's Motion for Modification of Sentence.”

— Michael W. Farlow, Assistant State's Attorney, Worcester County (State's response to Sifrit's petition)

What’s next

A Circuit Court judge for Montgomery County, where Sifrit was tried, has ordered a hearing on Sifrit's petition for a reduced sentence. That hearing is set for August 11, 2026. Sifrit will remain at the Maryland Correctional Training Center in the meantime.

The takeaway

This case highlights the ongoing debate around sentencing reform and 'second look' laws that allow certain offenders convicted as young adults to petition for reduced sentences after serving significant time. Sifrit's petition comes as Maryland's new Second Look Act takes effect, which could have implications for other similar cases in the state.