3 Midwest Emo Albums Now Old Enough to Buy Cigarettes

Albums from The Newfound Interest In Connecticut, Johnny Foreigner, and The Summer We Went West turn 21 this year.

Published on Mar. 5, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Three influential Midwest emo albums from the mid-2000s have now reached the legal age to purchase cigarettes, as they were all released in 2005. The albums include "Tell Me About the Long Dark Path Home" by The Newfound Interest In Connecticut, "We Left You Sleeping and Gone Now" by Johnny Foreigner, and "Following the Holy Moon Goddess" by The Summer We Went West.

Why it matters

These albums represent a pivotal moment in the Midwest emo genre, capturing the DIY, lo-fi sound and emotional lyricism that defined the scene in the early 2000s. As the albums reach their 21st anniversary, it marks the passing of time and the evolution of the genre, while also highlighting the enduring appeal and influence of these seminal works.

The details

The Newfound Interest In Connecticut blended math-rock instrumentals with emo vocals on "Tell Me About the Long Dark Path Home", creating a timeless yet distinctly 2005 sound. Johnny Foreigner's "We Left You Sleeping and Gone Now" showcased a chaotic, experimental take on the genre, with noticeable space between the various elements. "Following the Holy Moon Goddess" by The Summer We Went West featured the quintessential Midwest emo vocal style over a mix of acoustic and electric guitars, fuzzy electronics, and melancholy lyrics.

  • All three albums were released in 2005.

The players

The Newfound Interest In Connecticut

A short-lived Canadian band that blended intricate math-rock instrumentals with Midwest emo vocals and a lo-fi, recorded-in-the-basement texture.

Johnny Foreigner

A band from Birmingham, U.K. that captured the Midwest emo spirit on their 2005 album "We Left You Sleeping and Gone Now".

The Summer We Went West

A Midwest emo band that formed in College Park, Maryland in 2003 and released their only album, "Following the Holy Moon Goddess", in 2005.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

These three Midwest emo albums from 2005 represent a pivotal moment in the genre, capturing the raw, emotional, and DIY spirit that defined the scene at the time. As they reach their 21st anniversary, the albums serve as a reminder of the enduring influence and appeal of this era of emo music.