Pitcher Packy Naughton leaves 2026 debut after 3 pitches with injury

Naughton, attempting MLB comeback after multiple arm surgeries, exits game with apparent elbow issue

Apr. 9, 2026 at 3:07am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A cubist, geometric painting depicting a baseball pitcher's delivery broken down into sharp, overlapping planes of muted earth tones, conveying the anguish of another injury derailing a comeback.A fractured, geometric illustration captures the pain and frustration of Packy Naughton's latest injury setback in his MLB comeback attempt.Boston Today

Pitcher Packy Naughton, in the midst of an MLB comeback attempt following multiple arm injuries, left his 2026 debut on Wednesday with the Cardinals' Triple-A affiliate after just three pitches with another apparent injury. Naughton immediately grabbed at his left elbow in pain after delivering his third pitch of the game, and had to be tended to by the training staff before walking off the field.

Why it matters

Naughton was shaping up as a feel-good story in 2026 after missing most of the past three seasons due to various arm injuries, including a torn flexor tendon and Tommy John surgery. His latest setback raises concerns about his ability to make a successful return to the majors after such a long layoff.

The details

Facing White Sox farmhand Korey Lee in the bottom of the sixth inning, Naughton's 1-1 pitch missed well outside the zone, and left him in obvious discomfort. The 29-year-old immediately grabbed at his left elbow and bent over in pain as the Redbirds' catcher and training staff tended to him. Naughton then walked off the field while clutching his left elbow.

  • Naughton left his 2026 debut on Wednesday, April 9th.

The players

Packy Naughton

A 29-year-old pitcher attempting an MLB comeback with the Cardinals' Triple-A affiliate after missing most of the past three seasons due to various arm injuries.

Korey Lee

A White Sox farmhand who was facing Naughton when the injury occurred.

Leo Bernal

The Redbirds' catcher who tended to Naughton after he was injured.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“That's never a good sign. Hopefully nothing too serious there, just something he was trying to be cautious about.”

— Matt Swierad, Charlotte Knights announcer

“Even after the first pitch, it was kind of a sigh of relief. Elbow was intact, everything was good to go. All the work I've done; it paid off.”

— Packy Naughton

What’s next

The Cardinals will likely provide an update on the severity of Naughton's injury in the coming days, which will determine if he can continue his comeback attempt or if he faces another lengthy rehabilitation process.

The takeaway

Naughton's latest injury setback is a heartbreaking development for the pitcher, who had worked hard to return to the majors after multiple arm surgeries sidelined him for most of the past three seasons. The Cardinals will now have to wait and see if this latest elbow issue is another significant blow to Naughton's comeback hopes.