New Katterjohn subdivision could reshape historic Paducah neighborhood

Paducah Planning Commission approves 12 single-family homes on historic site, raising concerns from neighbors

Published on Feb. 14, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

The Paducah Planning Commission has approved a plan to turn the historic Katterjohn site into a new residential development of 12 single-family homes, each projected to cost around $400,000. While neighbors largely welcome the redevelopment, they are concerned that the inward-facing layout of the homes could clash with the character and traditions of the surrounding Jefferson and Broadway neighborhoods, including the Dogwood and Christmas trails.

Why it matters

The Katterjohn site has long been an important part of Paducah's history, and the new subdivision represents a significant change for the area. Residents are worried that the modern, inward-facing design of the homes may not fit with the established character of the historic neighborhood, potentially impacting local traditions and community identity.

The details

The Paducah Planning Commission has approved a plan to transform the historic Katterjohn site into a new 12-home residential development. Each of the single-family homes is projected to cost around $400,000. While neighbors generally welcome the redevelopment of the site, they are concerned that the inward-facing layout of the homes could clash with the character and traditions of the surrounding Jefferson and Broadway neighborhoods, including the popular Dogwood and Christmas trails.

  • The Paducah Planning Commission approved the new subdivision plan in February 2026.

The players

Paducah Planning Commission

The local government body responsible for reviewing and approving development plans in Paducah.

Katterjohn site

A historic site in Paducah that is being redeveloped into a new 12-home residential subdivision.

Jefferson and Broadway neighborhoods

The established historic neighborhoods surrounding the Katterjohn site, known for their character and local traditions like the Dogwood and Christmas trails.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“We must ensure the new development respects the character and traditions of the surrounding neighborhoods.”

— Paducah Resident (Patch.com)

What’s next

The Paducah City Commission still needs to approve the subdivision plan before construction can begin.

The takeaway

The new Katterjohn subdivision represents a balance between progress and preservation, as Paducah seeks to responsibly develop historic sites while maintaining the unique character of its established neighborhoods.