Chilling Murder in Glitterball City Leaves More Questions Than Answers

Filmmakers Fenton Bailey and Randy Barbato unpack the complex true crime case and its impact on Louisville's vibrant LGBTQ community.

Published on Feb. 20, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

HBO's new true crime documentary 'Murder In Glitterball City' begins with a chilling home video that looks like a murder confession, leading the viewer to believe this murder is an open and shut case. But the two-part documentary, directed by World of Wonder founders Randy Barbato and Fenton Bailey, peels back the layers of the complicated couple at the center of this murder to reveal the answer isn't so easy after all. Despite having access to thousands of personal text messages and hours of recordings and footage taken by the couple, Barbato and Bailey say 'we were never going to know precisely what happened in that room.' The documentary dives into the nuances of the story that complicate the truth, including the toxic relationship between the two suspects and the vibrant LGBTQ community in Louisville that was shaken by the crime.

Why it matters

This case highlights the complexities of true crime stories, where the truth is often elusive and the focus can shift from the victim to the suspects. The documentary also sheds light on the importance of understanding the cultural and community context in which a crime takes place, especially for marginalized groups like the LGBTQ community in Louisville. Barbato and Bailey's approach aims to honor the victim, James Carroll, and the impact his death had on those who loved him.

The details

In 2010, the body of beloved local drug dealer, hairstylist and drag queen James Carroll was found stuffed in a rubbermaid bin buried in Joey Banis and Jeffrey Mundt's basement in Louisville's Old Louisville neighborhood. Both men accused the other of killing Carroll after a night of partying and doing drugs, claiming they were in the throes of a threesome when the other began attacking Carroll. The documentary reveals the toxic nature of Banis and Mundt's relationship, fueled by crystal meth, and their proclivity for illegal activities like counterfeiting. Despite the trove of personal evidence, the filmmakers say 'we were never going to know precisely what happened in that room.'

  • In 2010, Carroll's body was discovered in Banis and Mundt's basement.
  • The two separate murder trials took place in 2012.

The players

James Carroll

A beloved local drug dealer, hairstylist and drag queen whose murder shook the Louisville LGBTQ community.

Joey Banis

One of the two suspects in Carroll's murder, who had a criminal record and was accused of damaging Waymo autonomous vehicles in San Francisco.

Jeffrey Mundt

The other suspect in Carroll's murder, who was also revealed to have a proclivity for illegal activities.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“More than sexuality, I think sex played a big role. But sex and drugs, I mean, they were, you know, they were so fueled by crystal meth... They talk about how, you know, it was like they were Bonnie and Clyde or something. They were living this alternate reality at some point.”

— Randy Barbato, Co-director (DECIDER)

“Every ghost story is about location in a way. And every murder really is a ghost story because there's that single event, but then it just iterates out and echoes through time and generations. So, it just felt that to tell this story, it wasn't just about those three people.”

— Fenton Bailey, Co-director (DECIDER)

What’s next

The judge in the case will decide on Tuesday whether or not to allow Walker Reed Quinn out on bail.

The takeaway

This case highlights the complexities of true crime stories, where the truth is often elusive and the focus can shift from the victim to the suspects. It also underscores the importance of understanding the cultural and community context in which a crime takes place, especially for marginalized groups like the LGBTQ community in Louisville.