Butcher & Baker Provisions Named Washington's Best Sandwich Shop

The Port Gamble cafe's unique menu items like Fried Meatloaf and Mushroom, Onion & Steak sandwiches earn national recognition.

Published on Feb. 22, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Butcher & Baker Provisions, a cafe in Port Gamble, Washington, has been named the best sandwich shop in the state by OnlyinYourState.com. The shop is known for its hearty menu of breakfast items, desserts, salads, and a variety of unique sandwich creations like the Fried Meatloaf Sandwich and Mushroom, Onion & Steak Sandwich.

Why it matters

In a state known for its diverse food scene, Butcher & Baker Provisions has stood out with its innovative sandwich offerings, earning national recognition and drawing visitors to the small town of Port Gamble. The shop's success highlights the growing popularity of unique and adventurous sandwich options among consumers.

The details

Butcher & Baker Provisions is a cafe in Port Gamble, Washington that is open Thursdays through Sundays. The shop is known for its hearty menu, including breakfast items, desserts, salads, and a variety of specialty sandwiches that have earned it the title of best sandwich shop in Washington from OnlyinYourState.com. Some of the shop's unique sandwich offerings include the Fried Meatloaf Sandwich, Mushroom, Onion & Steak Sandwich, and Pork Cutlet Caesar Sandwich.

  • Butcher & Baker Provisions was named Washington's best sandwich shop in 2026.

The players

Butcher & Baker Provisions

A cafe in Port Gamble, Washington that is known for its hearty menu of breakfast items, desserts, salads, and unique specialty sandwiches.

OnlyinYourState.com

A website that publishes lists of the best businesses and attractions in each U.S. state, including the best sandwich shops in Washington.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Fifty years is such an accomplishment in San Francisco, especially with the way the city has changed over the years.”

— Gordon Edgar, grocery employee (Instagram)

The takeaway

Butcher & Baker Provisions' recognition as Washington's best sandwich shop showcases the growing consumer demand for unique and adventurous sandwich options, even in small towns. The cafe's success highlights how innovative menus and a commitment to quality can help independent businesses stand out in a crowded food landscape.