Big Ten and SEC Egos Stall College Football Playoff Expansion

Disagreement over format and team selection prevents move to 16-team playoff

Jan. 31, 2026 at 2:15pm

Despite all 10 conference commissioners and Notre Dame's athletic director preferring an expanded 16-team College Football Playoff, the Big Ten and SEC's inability to agree on the format and selection process has kept the playoff at 12 teams for the upcoming 2026-2027 season. The two powerful conferences have wrestled control of the playoff but are now unable to work together due to their competing visions and egos, leaving the current 12-team format in place for now.

Why it matters

The failure to expand the College Football Playoff beyond 12 teams means the ongoing debate over which teams are "most deserving" will continue, as will arguments over the selection process. This preserves the traditional bowl season but limits the potential for more playoff games and revenue. The inability of the Big Ten and SEC to compromise highlights the power struggle between the conferences as they vie for control over the future of the sport.

The details

According to reports, all 10 conference commissioners and Notre Dame's athletic director Pete Bevacqua supported expanding the College Football Playoff to 16 teams for the 2026-2027 season. However, the Big Ten and SEC, the two most powerful conferences, could not agree on the format and selection process, leading to the playoff staying at 12 teams. The SEC proposed a 16-team format with 5 conference champions and 11 at-large bids, while the Big Ten wanted more automatic bids for the Power 4 conferences. This disagreement, described as "disgusting" by sources, prevented any expansion from happening.

  • The 12-team College Football Playoff format was introduced in the 2024-2025 season.
  • Discussions about expanding the playoff further began immediately after the 2025-2026 season.

The players

Big Ten

One of the Power 5 conferences in college football, known for its strong academic and athletic programs.

SEC

The Southeastern Conference, one of the Power 5 conferences in college football, known for its competitive and successful football programs.

Notre Dame

An independent college football program that is not affiliated with a conference, but is considered one of the most prestigious and successful programs in the sport.

Pete Bevacqua

The athletic director of Notre Dame University.

Kirk Herbstreit

A prominent college football analyst and commentator for ESPN.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The College Football Playoff management committee will continue discussions about potential future expansion, but any changes are unlikely to happen before the 2027-2028 season at the earliest.

The takeaway

The inability of the powerful Big Ten and SEC conferences to compromise on the format and selection process for an expanded College Football Playoff highlights the ongoing power struggle and ego clashes that are shaping the future of the sport. This preserves the current 12-team format, but limits the potential for growth and leaves unresolved debates over which teams are truly the "most deserving" of a playoff spot.