Michigan City man arrested for animal cruelty

Suspect identified through neighborhood surveillance footage and turned himself in

Published on Feb. 12, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A 28-year-old Michigan City resident named Michael Arroyo has been arrested and charged with one count of Cruelty to an Animal, a misdemeanor, after a video circulated on social media showing animal abuse. The incident was quickly investigated by the Michigan City Police Department and Animal Control, leading to the identification of the suspect and the dog being placed in the custody of another caregiver.

Why it matters

Animal abuse cases often generate significant public outcry and concern, highlighting the need for effective law enforcement response and community involvement to address such incidents. This case demonstrates the value of public reporting and the successful collaboration between police, animal control, and the prosecutor's office.

The details

On January 28th, the Michigan City Police Department and Animal Control were alerted to a video on social media depicting animal abuse. Investigators were able to identify the location, obtain additional surveillance footage, and identify the suspect as Michael Arroyo, the dog's owner. After a thorough investigation, an arrest warrant was issued, and Arroyo turned himself in on February 11th.

  • On January 28th, the incident was reported to police and animal control.
  • Within several days, the suspect was identified and the investigation was completed.
  • On February 11th, the suspect turned himself in to the LaPorte County Sheriff's Office.

The players

Michael Arroyo

A 28-year-old Michigan City resident who was charged with one count of Cruelty to an Animal, a misdemeanor, for the alleged abuse of his dog.

Michigan City Police Department

The law enforcement agency that coordinated the investigation and arrest in this case.

Michigan City Animal Control

The agency that worked with the police department to investigate the incident and ensure the welfare of the dog.

LaPorte County Prosecutor's Office

The office that reviewed the case and issued the arrest warrant for the suspect.

Lt. Painter

The Investigative Division Commander who led the investigation.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“This investigation highlights the critical importance of information provided by the public. Community members who report concerns and share information play a vital role in helping law enforcement and animal control respond quickly and effectively to incidents of abuse or neglect.”

— Michigan City Police Department (wimsradio.com)

What’s next

The judge will decide on Tuesday whether to allow Michael Arroyo to be released on bail.

The takeaway

This case demonstrates the power of community involvement and the importance of a swift and coordinated response from law enforcement and animal control agencies in addressing animal abuse incidents. It highlights the need for continued vigilance and public reporting to ensure the welfare of animals in the community.