Barstool's Portnoy Praises Indy Pizza Joints

Portnoy's reviews could shape the city's culinary reputation.

Apr. 9, 2026 at 7:14pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A vibrant, silkscreen-style illustration of a single, iconic pizza slice repeated in a grid pattern, using a bold, neon color palette and heavy black outlines to transform the everyday food item into a modern pop art piece.Portnoy's high-profile pizza reviews could reshape the culinary reputation of Indianapolis.Indianapolis Today

Dave Portnoy, the founder of Barstool Sports, recently visited several pizza restaurants in the Indianapolis area and shared his reviews of the local pizza scene. Portnoy, known for his popular "One Bite" pizza reviews, declared that Indianapolis is "very much not a pizza city," but highlighted a few standout pizzerias that he believes are serving some of the best pies in the city.

Why it matters

Portnoy's pizza reviews carry significant weight in the food and restaurant industry, and his assessment of Indianapolis' pizza landscape could have a major impact on the city's reputation and the popularity of its local pizza joints. As a prominent media figure, Portnoy's opinions can drive consumer interest and influence dining trends.

The details

During his visit, Portnoy reviewed several Indianapolis-area pizza restaurants, including King Dough, which he deemed to be among the best pizza in the city. King Dough is a local pizzeria that has gained a loyal following for its artisanal, wood-fired pies made with high-quality ingredients.

  • Portnoy visited the Indianapolis area in April 2026 to review local pizza restaurants.

The players

Dave Portnoy

The founder of Barstool Sports, a popular media company known for its sports and pop culture commentary, including Portnoy's widely followed "One Bite" pizza reviews.

King Dough

A local Indianapolis pizzeria that Portnoy highlighted as serving some of the best pizza in the city, known for its artisanal, wood-fired pies made with high-quality ingredients.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Indy is very much not a pizza city.”

— Dave Portnoy

The takeaway

Portnoy's high-profile reviews of Indianapolis' pizza scene could significantly influence the city's culinary reputation and the popularity of its local pizza joints, as his opinions carry significant weight in the industry.