Colts Urged to Find Contingency Plan for Star RB Jonathan Taylor

All-Pro running back has been the centerpiece of Indy's offense, but team may need to prepare for future

Apr. 7, 2026 at 2:25am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A fractured, multi-perspective painting depicting a football player in motion, with sharp, overlapping geometric planes in the Colts' blue and white colors, conceptually representing the team's need to have a backup plan for their star running back.The Colts' offense has become heavily reliant on star running back Jonathan Taylor, prompting calls for the team to prepare a contingency plan in case his production declines.Indianapolis Today

The Indianapolis Colts have relied heavily on star running back Jonathan Taylor as the centerpiece of their offense in recent seasons, with the All-Pro back racking up nearly 2,000 total yards and 20 touchdowns. However, experts are now urging the team to find a contingency plan in case Taylor's production or availability declines in the future.

Why it matters

Running backs often have shorter careers than other positions, and the Colts' offense has become highly dependent on Taylor's elite production. Preparing for a future without him could help the team maintain offensive stability and competitiveness if he were to get injured or see a drop-off in performance.

The details

Taylor has been a dominant force for the Colts, but the team may need to use an upcoming draft pick on a running back to develop a backup plan. This could be an unpopular move given Taylor's recent success, but it would provide insurance in case the star back's production declines or he suffers a serious injury.

  • Over the past five seasons, Jonathan Taylor has been the Colts' biggest offensive weapon.

The players

Jonathan Taylor

An All-Pro running back who has been the centerpiece of the Indianapolis Colts' offense in recent years.

Indianapolis Colts

The NFL team that has relied heavily on running back Jonathan Taylor as its offensive focal point.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

The Colts' reliance on Jonathan Taylor's elite production has made their offense highly dependent on him, so the team would be wise to use an upcoming draft pick to develop a contingency plan in case Taylor's performance declines or he suffers a serious injury in the future.