Longtime Carmel Resident Lawrence 'Larry' McMillan Passes Away at 70

McMillan, a longtime member of Colonial Hills Baptist Church, served as a pastor and paralegal before retiring due to cancer in 2024.

Mar. 24, 2026 at 5:48am

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Lawrence Joseph 'Larry' McMillan, a 70-year-old resident of Carmel, Indiana, passed away on March 21, 2026. McMillan had a long career that included serving as a pastor and paralegal before retiring in 2024 due to cancer. He was a longtime member of Colonial Hills Baptist Church and is survived by his wife, three children, and five grandchildren.

Why it matters

McMillan's life and career exemplify the dedication and service of many in the Carmel community, particularly within the local church. His passing marks the end of an era for Colonial Hills Baptist Church, where he was heavily involved for decades.

The details

After accepting Christ as his personal Savior in 1971, McMillan pursued a career in ministry, serving as an interim minister of music and then pastoring churches in Arizona. He later transitioned to a career as a paralegal before finishing his working years at an automotive shop in Carmel. McMillan retired in 2024 due to cancer, which ultimately led to his passing.

  • McMillan was born on March 15, 1956 in Indianapolis.
  • He trusted in Jesus Christ as his personal Savior on New Year's Eve, 1971.
  • McMillan married Peggy Sue Harrell on August 11, 1984.
  • He retired from Integrity Automotive in Carmel in November 2024 due to cancer.
  • McMillan passed away on March 21, 2026.

The players

Lawrence 'Larry' McMillan

A 70-year-old resident of Carmel, Indiana who had a long career as a pastor and paralegal before retiring in 2024 due to cancer.

Peggy Sue Harrell

McMillan's wife of 41 years.

Colonial Hills Baptist Church

The church where McMillan was a longtime member and served as an interim minister of music.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“Larry's final resting place will be in the Carmel Cemetery.”

— Bussell Family Funerals, Funeral Home

The takeaway

McMillan's life was marked by his deep faith, service to his community, and dedication to his family. His passing is a loss felt by all who knew him, and his legacy will continue to inspire those in the Carmel area.