NFL.com Ranks Colts' 2025 Draft Class as Below Average

Indianapolis Colts' rookie class struggles with injuries and inconsistent production in first season.

Feb. 11, 2026 at 3:23pm

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

According to a report on NFL.com, the Indianapolis Colts' 2025 draft class has been ranked as below average so far after their rookie season. The Colts' top pick, tight end Tyler Warren, had a strong start to the year but saw his production decline after the team's Week 11 bye. Other rookies like cornerback Justin Walley and linebacker Hunter Wohler also suffered season-ending injuries during training camp and preseason. While there were some bright spots, including promising performances from right tackle Jalen Travis and quarterback Riley Leonard, the overall draft class has room for improvement in their second season.

Why it matters

The Colts were one of the surprise teams in the NFL in 2025, starting 8-2 before faltering down the stretch. Their rookie class was expected to play a big role in the team's success, so the struggles and injuries to key draft picks was a significant factor in their late-season collapse. As the Colts look to build on their promising start, getting more consistent production from this draft class will be crucial to their hopes of making the playoffs in 2026.

The details

According to the NFL.com analysis, the Colts' 2025 draft class was led by tight end Tyler Warren, their first-round pick. Warren had a strong start to the season, leading all NFL tight ends in receiving yards through Week 10. However, his production fell off sharply after the team's Week 11 bye, with his yards per reception dropping from 12.3 to just 7.7. The Colts' other top picks, including edge rusher JT Tuimoloau, cornerback Justin Walley, and linebacker Hunter Wohler, all struggled with injuries, with Walley and Wohler suffering season-ending setbacks. The Colts did get some promising performances from fourth-round tackle Jalen Travis and sixth-round quarterback Riley Leonard, but overall the class has room for improvement in their second season.

  • Through Week 10, Tyler Warren led all NFL tight ends in receiving yards.
  • After the Colts' Week 11 bye, Warren's production declined sharply.
  • Cornerback Justin Walley and linebacker Hunter Wohler suffered season-ending injuries during training camp and preseason.

The players

Tyler Warren

The Colts' first-round pick in 2025, a tight end who had a strong start to his rookie season before seeing his production decline after the team's Week 11 bye.

JT Tuimoloau

The Colts' second-round pick in 2025, an edge rusher who was limited to 13 games and 0 sacks as a rookie.

Justin Walley

The Colts' third-round pick in 2025, a cornerback who suffered a season-ending injury during training camp.

Jalen Travis

The Colts' fourth-round pick in 2025, a right tackle who made 4 starts in relief of veteran Braden Smith down the stretch.

Riley Leonard

The Colts' sixth-round pick in 2025, a quarterback who showed promise in his first career start against the Houston Texans in the regular season finale.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What’s next

The Colts will need to get more production from their 2025 draft class, especially second-round pick JT Tuimoloau and third-round pick Justin Walley, who missed most of his rookie season due to injury. Improving the overall performance of this group will be crucial as the Colts look to build on their promising 8-2 start and make the playoffs in 2026.

The takeaway

The struggles and injuries of the Colts' 2025 rookie class were a significant factor in the team's late-season collapse, highlighting the importance of getting consistent production from young players. As the Colts look to bounce back in 2026, developing this draft class will be a top priority for the organization.