Identical Twin Brothers Defy Political Divide

Indianapolis siblings with opposing political views show how family ties can endure America's toxic partisanship.

Published on Feb. 9, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Nick and Nathan Roberts are identical twin brothers from Indianapolis who have diametrically opposed political views. Nick is a young Democratic city-county counselor, while Nathan is a grassroots activist and co-founder of a conservative anti-immigration nonprofit. Despite their stark political differences, the twins have maintained a close relationship, demonstrating how family bonds can transcend deep partisan divides.

Why it matters

In an era of heightened political polarization, where families and friends often cut ties over political disagreements, the Roberts twins offer a refreshing counternarrative. Their ability to respectfully disagree and stay connected highlights the possibility of bridging divides and preserving important relationships, even in the face of deep ideological differences.

The details

The twins' political split began around 2015, when Donald Trump announced his presidential campaign. While Nick fell in love with Bernie Sanders' democratic socialist platform, Nathan was immediately captivated by Trump's restrictionist immigration policies. Despite their divergent political paths, the Roberts family dynamic prevented the split from becoming toxic. Their grandparents and extended family represented a range of political views, which allowed the twins to grow up in an environment of respectful dialogue and exposure to different life experiences.

  • In 2015, the twins' political divide began to emerge as Donald Trump announced his presidential campaign.
  • In 2020 and 2024, Nick Roberts served as a delegate for Kamala Harris's presidential campaigns.
  • Late last year, Nick Roberts posted a viral PSA warning his followers that if they spotted someone who looked exactly like him at a Trump event or wearing a MAGA hat, it was not actually him—it was his brother.

The players

Nick Roberts

A 24-year-old Democratic city-county counselor in Indianapolis, the youngest in the city's history. He served as a delegate for Kamala Harris in both her 2020 and 2024 presidential campaigns.

Nathan Roberts

Nick's identical twin brother, a grassroots activist and co-founder of Save Heritage Indiana, a conservative anti-immigration nonprofit that aligns closely with the Trump administration's immigration policies.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

What they’re saying

“When Trump announced, when he came down the golden escalator, I fell in love. I thought he was awesome. Everything he stood for. I was totally all about it.”

— Nathan Roberts, Grassroots Activist (The 1600 Podcast)

“Admittedly, I was so cringe. I was like a Bernie Bro to the death. I was the biggest Bernie guy. And then like by summer, I came around to Hillary.”

— Nick Roberts, Democratic City-County Counselor (The 1600 Podcast)

“I don't feel like cutting people out of your family actually does anything to further the cause. When you cut people out of your family, people hope that six months from now, they'll get their uncle saying, 'Oh, you know what, I voted for Trump. You're so right. I see the light now.' That doesn't happen.”

— Nick Roberts, Democratic City-County Counselor (The 1600 Podcast)

What’s next

The twins plan to continue their public appearances and discussions, hoping to serve as a model for how families can navigate deep political divisions while maintaining strong bonds.

The takeaway

The Roberts twins' ability to respectfully disagree and stay connected despite their stark political differences offers a powerful example of how family ties can endure in an era of heightened partisanship. Their story highlights the possibility of bridging divides and preserving important relationships, even in the face of deep ideological differences.