Heartbreak in Shelbyville: Tindley Ends Trinity's Run in a 3-OT Classic

Class A No. 7 Trinity Lutheran falls to Indianapolis Tindley 46-44 in triple overtime thriller.

Published on Feb. 16, 2026

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

Tournament basketball doesn't always end with a fairy tale. Sometimes it ends with a final possession, legs made of jelly, and a scoreboard that feels like it's staring back at you. That was the reality for Class A No. 7 Trinity Lutheran, as the Cougars saw an unforgettable season come to a close in the Shelbyville Semistate, falling to Indianapolis Tindley 46-44 in triple overtime.

Why it matters

Trinity Lutheran had an impressive 20-5 season built on consistency, toughness, and a strong team identity. Their heartbreaking loss in triple overtime highlights the unpredictable nature of tournament basketball and the emotional toll it can take on players and fans alike.

The details

The Cougars and Tigers battled through three extra periods, with neither team able to pull away. Trinity fought valiantly but ultimately came up just short, losing by a final score of 46-44.

  • The game took place on February 16, 2026 in the Shelbyville Semistate.

The players

Trinity Lutheran

A Class A high school basketball team that finished the season with a 20-5 record.

Indianapolis Tindley

The opponent that defeated Trinity Lutheran 46-44 in triple overtime.

Got photos? Submit your photos here. ›

The takeaway

Trinity Lutheran's heartbreaking loss in triple overtime highlights the unpredictable nature of tournament basketball and the emotional toll it can take on players and fans. Despite the tough ending, the Cougars can be proud of their impressive 20-5 season and the strong team identity they built throughout the year.