Man Convicted of Brutal Stabbing Death in Round Lake Beach

Got story updates? Submit your updates here. ›

A 33-year-old man from Grayslake, Illinois has been convicted of first-degree murder following a brutal 2022 stabbing that left a 37-year-old victim dead with over 40 stab wounds. The suspect, Jesus Vargas, had initially claimed self-defense, but DNA evidence from the murder weapon conflicted with his story. Vargas now faces life in prison for the crime.

Why it matters

This case highlights the challenges law enforcement faces in determining the true circumstances of a violent crime when a suspect claims self-defense. The high number of stab wounds on the victim and the contradictory DNA evidence raise questions about the legitimacy of Vargas' self-defense claim and the potential for repeat violent offenders to exploit legal loopholes.

The details

Prosecutors charged Jesus Vargas, 33, of Grayslake after police responded to a call in February 2022 and found the body of Brian Mahdee, 37, also of Grayslake, with multiple stab wounds. Witnesses said Vargas had brutally attacked Mahdee while he was seated and using his phone, and then tried to clean up the scene and discourage people from calling the police. Vargas claimed self-defense, but DNA evidence from the murder weapon contradicted his story. Investigators determined that Mahdee had suffered over 40 stab wounds throughout his body.

• In February 2022, police responded to the incident in Round Lake Beach.
• On March 6, 2026, a jury convicted Vargas of first-degree murder following a five-day trial.

What’s next

Vargas is due back in court on Tuesday, April 28 for sentencing, where he faces a potential life sentence.